EpisodesThe Main PodSeason 2026/27

The Bruno Bombshell
DownloadOr listen in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Pocket Casts, the AVP app or RSS
Show notes
On this edition of the ArsenalVision Podcast, Elliot is joined by Tim to discuss every aspect of the potential move for Bruno Guimaraes. There’s also a bit on other incomings and outgoings as well as thoughts on Meslier.
Get an exclusive NordVPN deal + 4 months extra at https://nordvpn.com/arsenalvision
Get an exclusive 15% discount on Saily data plans! Use code ARSENALVISION at checkout. Download Saily app or go to https://saily.com/arsenalvision
Check out the merch store at https://shop.arsenalvisionpodcast.com
Chapters
Watch it
Transcript
Read the transcript
Elliot Smith0:33Remember that player you hate and you've hated for years? Well you love him now. This is the ArsenalVision Postmatch Podcast Finding Billy Speaking Blackman Twitter game. Hello, buddy! Bruno Guimarães. Hate him. Can't stand him. Remember that time he did that thing? Did that thing to Jorginho with the elbow? And he's been he's been mean to us and a bit rough with us? Well, we love him now because he might be ours, because he wants to be at Arsenal once you want to be at Arsenal. You're in the fold, or are you? We'll find out what Tim thinks of that. Clive gave his thoughts on the Bruno stuff yesterday, along with the Meslier stuff yesterday, along with a bit on what's going on with our academy, as some talent drains, but some new people come in to maybe protect the growth and development of the academy. So you can listen to that over on Patreon. Saliba 50s of code, couple of quid. You're in. Tomorrow we'll have a Friday night, Clive. Today we have Tim. Tomorrow we'll have a World Cup Daily. It's all happening. It's all happening. The football is happening. Watch it. Watch the football. We're gonna get back to doing some scouting videos. Probably a Bruno Scouting video, but we scouted him once. We have a collection called Scouting Videos. If you go. To the Patreon, you look up collections, you can see every single scouting video we've done. We've done Barcola, we've done Bruno Guy Marais, we've done all these solis. Done. You can go watch it. And these aren't just YouTube clips. This is the real scouting stuff, the good stuff. So I would enjoy it if you would watch it. You can watch Clive analyze the player, and then you can watch me do things like go, ooh, it's really, really good stuff.
Elliot Smith1:52We've got an iOS app coming. There'll be more on that soon. And then the Android app will follow it. It'll allow you to stay connected with the pod. You can have your regular pods in there. If you're a patron, you can have your patron pods in there. You'll be able to submit mailbag questions in there, watch the YouTube videos from there. Yeah, should be good. And we're gonna hopefully keep adding things to that to make that worthwhile for you. So we look forward to giving you news on that. But I think that covers it for introductory nonsense. I do the introductory nonsense just because I feel like you don't want to get right into the chat. Right. You you wanna you wanna be eased into the chat. And the introductory nonsense is kinda like it's like that warm that it's like the bath water, if it's too hot and you try to get in, it scolds you, you need just a little bit of easing in. But now you're ready to be scolded with the hot takes of the fireman himself. Tim Stillman, hello Tim. How you doing?
Tim Stillman2:37Hello there. Yeah, good, thank you. Good. It's warm here. So, yeah.
Elliot Smith2:42Yeah, yeah, so you're ready to get hot. All right, look, I have to say I think this must be an interesting time for you. It's been a it's been a bad time for Brazil. It's been a good time for England on the pitch. Now there's a Brazilian who missed a penalty, who is who is a pariah in Brazil, who may be coming to Arsenal. You must be pulled in a million directions. Can I just ask you how you're holding up with the Brazil and England thing first in your household, and then we can get to the Bruno stuff.
Tim Stillman3:06Yeah, actually not as bad is a very loaded word to use, but I think the thing is the expectation around Brazil is really dropping. I think this is really maybe not as painful because it's really starting to become expected. Now it's 24 years since they last won the World Cup. And I think the thinking is that their time might be done as a super elite footballing nation. I'm not as sure about that. I do think just by the size of their population, I think they'll put together a very good team or squad at some point. But yeah, I think it's I think it's actually a really interesting question around the World Cup, some of these countries that have this reputation, the stereotype of Brazilian football has not been true for longer than I've been alive. That that stereotype that people have, that's from before I was born. Right. That's nearly half
Tim Stillman4:12A century ago. That stuff was true, but it's endured for so long. And then it's the same with countries like Netherlands, right? There's the whole total football thing. But actually, Netherlands have been bad for a long time now. And Germany have gone out the last three World Cups early and Italy haven't qualified for the last three. So I think there's a really interesting question about with younger generations, are those reputations going to endure? Do young people look at Netherlands and think total football, Johan Cruyff, Dennis Bergkamp, Marco van Basten, all of that from before they were born? And same with Brazil, are people going to be like, well, they won the World Cup last time 24 years ago. How enduring are some of these reputations
Elliot Smith4:57It's an interesting question.
Tim Stillman4:59Is, I think, a really interesting question that's really emerging. From this World Cup.
Elliot Smith5:06Yeah, and just to show you that Arsenal isn't the only online community where absurd debates and discussions happen, a not insignificant portion of the online Brazil footballing fan base is having a debate about whether the move from a Catholic Brazil to a Protestant Brazil is the reason for the change in football style.
Tim Stillman5:27Pentecostal debate, yeah.
Elliot Smith5:28There yeah, the Pentecostal debate. And and I will say my personal opinion on that, which no one needs, but I'll do super quickly is simply the Brazil team is now increasingly educated. F their football education and their football career occurs in Europe, in leagues that have a particular style. And so I think the cultural identity of the Brazil team is going to be increasingly defined by whatever the identity of football in Europe is, right? Because their players are playing where? In the Premier League, in La Liga. In Serie A, in League on. And if that's where you're brought up and that's where you're playing, then whatever the prevailing style of football is in those areas, that's the football that you're going to be a purveyor of. That's it, So
Tim Stillman6:12Yeah, and it causes a disconnect with fans as well. Most of the fans just don't connect with the players because most of them leave so early even in the build up to Brazil, Norway when those Gabriel Holland comps were doing the rounds I saw so many Brazilians on my timeline that were just like I didn't know Gabriel was like this because he left like he barely played in Brazil He went to France when he was a teenager then came to us and so they don't forge those connections a player plays for you stays till his early twenties or whatever. Now they're gone at 17, 18. So you never see them play. So that's created a, an emotional and cultural distance as well. And then Brazil started doing all this stuff with Nike where they were doing road shows because they're such a big brand. They'd go and play in the U S they're playing the middle East. So they wouldn't play at home very much. Um, and, and again, this, this could all like, there's undoubtedly there's been a homogenization of football. Ultimately, you look at it, it's very UEFA dominated. Again,
Tim Stillman7:17These final stages, but then you've got, someone like Morocco, Morocco, a consistent tournament team now. But quite a lot of it is built on players who are second generation and have also been raised playing in Europe. And then, know, success stories like Cape Verde and Suriname and stuff like that. And actually the reality of their teams is that most of them are diaspora and playing in Europe. So actually the European domination is even bigger than it looks.
Elliot Smith7:54Yeah.
Tim Stillman7:55And I just find this stuff really, really interesting. Are some of these teams I mentioned at the outset, Netherlands, Germany, Italy, Brazil, are they losing their identity? Are they too obsessed with identity? Is it possible to have a national footballing identity anymore? I think all of that is really, really fascinating and really been crystallized by particularly the last two World Cups, I think, the post-COVID World Cup, shall we say, I think really shown, I think. I don't know whether plates are shifting, but an evolution in global football.
Elliot Smith8:35Yeah, I have to say, I think the international game is getting closer to the club game in terms of the way teams play. You see it now, right? Building in a two three or a three two, defending in a four two out of possession, but in first phase of build up, there's those three defenders, there's those tucked in fullback. You see a lot of familiar things in the international game and in the club game. I have a theory though, and it's a theory of why I think first of all, Brazil may feel some of their footballing identity is is withering. But I think it's also why we as Arsenal supporters are struggling with the question of who's the left wing player we should get? Where are these great players? I think football, because defenders are getting better, because fullbacks are getting better, because athleticism is improving and organizational defending is improving, I think football is becoming a more collectivist sport. And I think there is less ability for one on one individual brilliance on the ball to decide games in the way it has always done. The years of a Ronaldinho dancing on the ball or an R9 beating four defenders on his way to the goal or even Messi doing that. Defenders are better. Defenses are more organized. Fullbacks can defend 1v1 better than they have. And so the game is about structure. It is about c collaboration and cooperation. It is about set pieces. And why is it about set pieces? In part because the defenses are better at stopping you from those individual moves.
Elliot Smith10:01And while I think there's always exceptions to the rule, I don't think it's that we don't have talented players. I think the talent defensively is starting to match the talent in attack in a way it hasn't historically, especially at lower teams, especially in the Premier League, where there's a lot of money. And so, Tim, that ability to find that player where like, gosh, look at what he can do. He can just devastate 1v1. There are some examples of it. I'm not saying there are none, and some of them are 18 year olds like Lamin Yamal. But even still, his strength is actually how he provides for others, right? But Kayo Saka, why is he so dominant when he's fit? It's not his eye-catching Joga Benito dancing on the ball. It's the intelligence with which he brings others into play and his decision-making. And I really do think that that is changing how we think about football and how we think about the identity of individual national teams that were built around Flair, because I don't know that Flair players. Are in abundance able to decide games the way they so often did down the years,
Tim Stillman11:04Yeah, yeah, definitely not. It's a lot more systemic nowadays, but then, yeah.
Elliot Smith11:08Mm-hmm. As Arsenal approved, right? A team of no real clear attacking stars winning the Premier League and nearly winning the Champions League.
Tim Stillman11:16But, and this is where football is so great because it's just never ending. It's just an absolute hamster wheel. We're saying all of this. Look at the top scorers list of the World Cup. It's the best players in the world. It's Harland, it's Mbappe, it's Messi. The other thing about this tournament is that the stars have turned up. And usually in a World Cup top scoring list, you'll get someone like out of nowhere, you'll get someone. And quite often they'll have scored a hat trick against some no-hopers in the group stage and then they'll get one or two more or something and it'll be like, this guy got five goals at the World Cup and no one had ever heard of him before. Whereas this World Cup is like, no, it's Harland and Bappi, Messi and Kane. They're all going for the golden boot together. And obviously there's more games now as well, but it's like, and they're all probably like, whoever wins it is going to break the record for a golden boot or a World Cup. So in many senses, the other teaching this World Cup is arguably that it's the stars that are making it right, because those are the ones that break the system. So Mbappe
Elliot Smith12:25Yeah. But but what's interesting, Tim?
Tim Stillman12:28Can break your system. Harland can break your system. Not many players can, but the ones that really can are hugely valuable, obviously.
Elliot Smith12:37Absolutely, and I agree with that. But I'd I'd say it's interesting, right? What makes all those players special, I think, is their finishers, right? Holland is a finisher. Messi is no longer the dribble eight guys to score guy. He's a finisher. Mbappe, I guess, can do he's he's extraordinary, right? But but it's his ability to just get a half yard of space and then finish. Kane, of course, isn't gonna beat anybody, but look at some of the goals he scores. He just finishes from all angles. And I think that, and again, you're always gonna see things in the way that enlarges your point, but I think in a in a footballing landscape where you can't dance past five or six guys and score the stunning solo goal, the guys who can take a half yard of space and turn it into a goal become so much more valuable. And we're really seeing now Holland aside, maybe Mbappe aside, there's there's there's two types of striker in football. There's the finisher. There's Kane who can stand still at the top of the box and just finish. Lewandowski has a bit of that, right? For Barcelona. Holland, Holland can run in behind fish. And then there's the false nines, and there's probably more false nines than anything else because they can at least influence the game. I don't know. It's an interesting debate for another time. We got to get into the Bruno stuff, but I definitely think that change to more collectivism and more and less one-on-one individualist.
Elliot Smith14:04Brilliance is also why we look around the football landscape knowing we need a left wide attacker, and we're like, is it Barkala? Is there anybody else? Is it Rafa Liao? And why do we go to a Rafa Liau who we know isn't setting the world on fire? It's because he's one of those rare examples of an individualistically brilliant player. But is that really what we need? Okay, Bruno Gamerich. Yesterday, if you missed it, David Ornstein dropped the Oren Bomb, and it hit. It hit its target, which is Arsenal supporters and Newcastle supporters, saying that Bruno has told Newcastle he wants to come to Arsenal, he's ready to leave. We've made a bid for 60 million. I don't think that'll get it done. And it's been reported it won't get it done. It is worth noting that Newcastle have already lost Gordon and already lost Tanali. And I think it would be unprecedented for a club of their size, whatever you think of them, to lose Tanali, Gordon, and Bruno, which are arguably their three best players, all in the same window. But it may happen. It would certainly not make them happy. Which I guess we're supposed to say is funny. But I think it would make us happy. So the very first thing, Tim, I need to just ask you, before we get into the fit and all those other things is how do you feel about this player for Arsenal? He will be 29 during this season. He will probably cost in excess of 70 million when it's all said and done. How do you feel about this player though? Forget the dynamics of the move, this player for Arsenal.
Tim Stillman15:26Yeah, I think he ticks a lot of boxes. He has a lot of stuff we don't have. I think it's really interesting actually with both our main targets how I feel like as Arsenal fans we've mischaracterized them and maybe based on the play on the way those players have played against us. But get the spreadsheets out and what does Bruno come up with? It's like progressive passes, line breaking passes, through balls like that that's really what he does and that's what we don't do enough of. But he also gives us resilience in an area where we probably need it. It's probably the one area of the squad where if we're saying that Norgard is not really, when I say a serious member, I don't mean that personally, but in an on-pitch sense, a serious part of the squad, then he gives us that bit of resilience and he can. He can do a bit of what Rice does. He can do a bit of what Merino does. He can do a bit of what Zubimendi does. He can, I don't want to say fill in because I don't think he'd be a fill in player, but he could do all of those jobs. Basically, he could be in a double pivot. He could be slightly further forward. You could probably even play him as a lone six. He's a bit like Rice, I think maybe in that respect and that he's he's versatile within those profiles. But what he does is he
Tim Stillman16:52Is progressive passing. That's his superpower. That's what we don't do enough of. That's why we get the horseshoe a little bit. I think we were eighth in the division for progressive passes last season. We were sixth for passes completed. These are not normal numbers for a Premier League champion and it's where we need to get better. I'll echo the discussion you and Clive had on the Patreon yesterday, which is, about the age profile and stuff like that. But actually, once you're at the mountaintop, you're trying to stay there. You're not you're not in a four or five year project anymore. You've reached the summit and you want to stay there and you want to get a bit better. And so you do need prime age guys for that. And I guess the most crude example I could find for that is Manchester United buying Robin van Persie when he was 29. They lost the league on goal difference. They bought the best goal scorer and they won the league the next year. Sometimes it is, you're trying to you're trying to stay on base a little bit. So, and also I think this summer, it's not like last summer in terms of how busy we're going to be. We've got the back, well the back of maybe the third goalkeeper that's done. There might be a defender, but
Tim Stillman18:13Bruno and Morgan Rogers, that really feels like the meat. It doesn't feel like this is gonna be another six or seven guys in, six or seven guys out. This feels like Bruno will come in, Norgard will go, Rogers will come in, Trossard will go, maybe White will go in the defense. It does feel a bit more one in one out. And I think within that framework as well, you can definitely take a guy who's 28. And again, the point you made yesterday on the Patreon as well. If he's 26 and he's got four years on his contract at Newcastle, how much does he cost then?
Elliot Smith18:48There gosh, there's so much there, Tim. I wanna just start with him as the player though. This is the rare example, I think, of a player who gives you progression, creativity, and out-of-possession work rate and impact involvement. Yeah. That
Tim Stillman19:08He's an all-rounder, he's a proper all-rounder. Yeah.
Elliot Smith19:10Fits what we do like because for example, many people may know already. I'm obsessed with Adam Morton. I think Adam Morton is a cheat code. In passes between the lines and through balls in behind. I he's he's Trent in midfield, he's he's a bit of sesk in midfield if I may invoke that. He is, at least in my view, a bit of a liability out of possession. Now, you could make the argument we have Declan Rice mate. He can be a bit of a liability. But what if Declan Rice can't play and you're trotting out, Adam Morton and who? And Zubimendi, I guess? Maybe miles, it starts to look a little lightweight for me in terms of our style and what we want to do. What I love about Bruno is he gives you the ability to add the things that are missing without taking away the things that are working, if that makes sense. Right?
Elliot Smith20:11If you look at a Vitinor Jauneves at PSG, they're not. Assist monsters. They're not goal creators particularly, but they do a bit of everything. They allow PSG to be one of the best out-of-possession teams and in possession teams simultaneously. And I think you get some of that from Bruno. Worth noting, he had in the last three seasons in the Premier League, seven goals and eight assists, five goals, six assists. This season, nine goals and five assists. Now, two of those were penalties. So if you want to say seven non-penalty goals and five assists, that's 14 goal involvements from central midfield. That's that's real good. You will you'll absolutely take that. So for me, the player is an excellent proven Premier League player who can play with Zubimendi, with Myles, with Rice, with Odegaard, with any of those players, as are six or eight or however you want to think about those players, without us losing too much. Now look, you take a Declan Rice out your midfield, you're never gonna be as good as if a Declan Rice is in your midfield.
Elliot Smith21:15But if you believe that we may have to play a bit without Rice this season, at least to start the season, I think Bruno Guimarães gives you more ability to retain that balance. And then if you have Bruno and Rice in midfield, you have tremendous range. You have range in passing, range in carrying. Both of them can arrive into the final third and score goals and provide assists. But then think of what you can do with the third midfielder. You can have anything you want in there. You want a Morgan Rogers who's not really going to do much in passing. You want Eberetcha Eze, who we know has struggled to get on the ball, need someone to link it to him. No problem. You want Odegaard and you want to be PSG and have the ball for 85% of the time and play 4,000 passes, you can do that. You you have a number of different ways of doing it. And this is where the age thing comes in too. Because I really believe this, Tim. When you're in your winning window, you need to buy players that make you better right now, today. Because a player that makes you better in three seasons is all well and good. But if they don't make you better today, you could lose the years when you can win a title. As we know, twenty-two years it took us to get back to winning a title, but it took us four years of trying, of being right there. This is a guy who keeps us right there at the top of the Premier League game from a midfield standpoint. And guess what? If you get two good years out of him, and by year three he's starting to decline, and you win two Premier Leagues, mate.
Elliot Smith22:43I don't give a shit what the third year is. And by the way, what a perfect way to say to Myles Lewis-Skelly, we're gonna play you a lot this season. We're gonna play you a lot next season, but you are in a position now to develop into midfield. Max Dowman, Ethan Winary, if we want, you're in a position to develop, to find some minutes, but not have to win us a title right away. I think he's a bridge to the future while maintaining our incredibly high floor and high ceiling in the present. But I want to give you another angle on this that that I want to get your thoughts on, Tim, which is just value. It seems like the market used to forget how important it was to buy pre-prime age players. And you used to see outrageous fees and outrageous transfers for older players. Robin Van Persie, as great as United did with him for a season, became unusable one season later. They got one season out of him. They won a title. And they got an extraordinary season. And I doubt any United fan would say that was a bad transfer. But really, economically, or however you want to look at it, it probably wasn't a great transfer. He he was w usable for one season. But
Elliot Smith23:43Has the market moved too much the other way? Because in my mind, Bruno Guimarães today is better than Elliot Anderson today. Now, Elliot Anderson is 23 and Bruno is 28. But Elliot Anderson's 116 million. Tanali, who's two years younger, is a hundred million. If you can get the better player for 70 million, could you make an argument that there might be a little bit of a market inefficiency developing or efficiency developing in the older bracket? Where these teams who are trying to build themselves up are not competing for talent. And if Bruno's elite through his thirty one year old season, seventy million for him versus one sixteen for Anderson or a hundred for Tanali, to me, actually looks like you're exploiting a market efficiency with the understanding that what you don't get, likely, is any resale value. And that that's really where the pitfall is,
Tim Stillman24:34Of course, but then what resale value a man city going to get out of Elliot Anderson? Like that. But yeah.
Elliot Smith24:41None, 'cause you're either gonna keep him until he's thirty four if he's good, or he's gonna be bad and no one's gonna wanna buy him. So
Tim Stillman24:47That. So at the top end of the market, there is no resale value anyway, basically, because no one's no one's got Man City are at the top of the food chain. No one is going to like you say, the only reason he'd go is if he's been bad and no one will pay for him anyway, basically. So, at a certain point, the idea of resale value becomes a bit moot anyway. Because not like and that's what Man City do, right? What did they do with Kevin De Bruyne? They kept him till his hamstrings fell off. What did they do with Aguero? They kept him until, mean, in fact, he retired like he went to Barca and his medical uncovered some kind of heart issue. And that's what they're going to do with Roger as well. They are going to write, they're going to write that until it's got no legs anymore. So yeah, at a certain point. The resell value becomes a bit moot anyway. And actually what you're looking at, if you're looking at it, know, purely financially, you're looking at a more, amortization and things like that. And actually if, if it makes you can get good book value without necessarily selling somebody. And yeah, I even think of, man United buying Andre Santos from Chelsea.
Elliot Smith26:08I wanted to ask you about that. Yeah.
Tim Stillman26:09Yeah for around 50 million. I think that looks a really good buy at quite a good price. And
Elliot Smith26:13I agree. Yeah.
Tim Stillman26:14What's interesting about that to me is that Chelsea are like the is it the ball case or the bear case that's the bad one?
Elliot Smith26:22Bull is good, bear is bad.
Tim Stillman26:24Right so they're the bear case they've bought so much young talent and stuck so many of them on long contracts that they're getting picked off here because it's like we can't sell a lot of these guys. So if we get, it's the same with Madueke, right? I'm not, I'm not pretending that Madueke is a player that particularly changes their world, but they put themselves in a situation where it's like 50 million. We have to take it because we've created this sell to buy model. And actually we're not finding a lot of value because we're buying loads and loads of young players. That's a very noisy market anyway, lots of variables in it. And actually we're finding we can't sell a lot of these guys. So when we do get. A reasonable offer for a good player, we have to take it. And the other thing about the buy to sell model now is there is only one market really, and that's the Premier League. So you have to sell to your competitors like that. That's that's the other again, Chelsea being the bear case. That's the other position they've put themselves in is that they're strengthening all their rivals because Napoli can't buy like, what's his name, Gittins?
Elliot Smith27:34Guy who's been on a hundred and sixty thousand a week. No. They there's they have no ability to buy that player unless the fee's ten million. Yeah.
Tim Stillman27:41Yeah, exactly. What Chelsea are essentially doing is like they helped us out by with Madueke. Thanks very much. They're helping Man United help with Santos. Thanks very much. So I think there are some old ideas about the market maybe in particularly with regulations changing and SCR instead of PSR and stuff like
Elliot Smith28:05Mm. PSR. Mm-hmm.
Tim Stillman28:07That. It's also not a massive coincidence. I don't think our two main targets are from Aston Villa and Newcastle who are teams who are in trouble on particularly on UEFA, which is a lot more stringent. They're in trouble on UEFA and you mentioned there about Newcastle they might sell three players in one summer. But I think the interesting thing about that is two of those sales happened before June 30th. So it's in one summer. But it's over two bookkeeping periods if they sell us Bruno as well. And that might be, the Tenali and Gordon sales have potentially solved. Yeah, exactly. But then they've got they've got this bookkeeping period
Elliot Smith28:44Mm-hmm. Helped their twenty six. Yeah, this is helping their twenty seven.
Tim Stillman28:52And they've got to sell someone else really, particularly because they've got to do a bit of a rebuild and they've got to fund it and they've got to, so it's almost like the Tenali and Gordon sales, not that they don't count. That's overstating it. But that belongs to a different bookkeeping period now. So you've got all of these, these different things and us and Tottenham to be fair and Tottenham are a club who obviously made tons of mistakes, but pure business terms, their wage to revenue ratio has been low, which is now giving them the ability to go and spend a hundred million on Tonali because they're not in any trouble. They're also not in Europe. So they can push the limits a bit because they won't be for one year, they won't be subject to UEFA and all of that. So I'm with you. I think there are loads of these slight changes in the market that we're going to see and one of them is going to be, well, it already is, like clubs circling around guys like Newcastle and Villa who've had to overspend to come to the level that they're at.
Tim Stillman29:57And that's the part of the argument the Newcastle and Villa fans that complain about the regulations conveniently ignore. They're like, we can't compete because we can't spend all this. It's like, no, no, no, no. You've already spent it. That's what's got you to this level. Aston Villa, we're in the championship, right, until 2019. And you've suddenly become a Champions League club that wins the Europa League. Sorry, how did you do that? Because you spent a lot of money. And so, yeah, and so there's all these slightly different dynamics going on. And I do think we're in a very, very good, a very good position to take advantage of some of those.
Elliot Smith30:36There's there's so many things about this that I find so interesting. Tim, one is really a change of perspective for me, but I will say just from a Newcastle standpoint, you think about what they thought they were gonna get with the Saudi takeover. And now you look at Elliot Anderson that they sold, Ilonga that they sold, Isaac that they sold, Tanali, Gordon, maybe Bruno. It really feels like they just are slipping away from being a team that that's going to be competing for even European places at this rate. It is what it is. I won't I won't cry any tears about it, but it is an interesting thing to observe. Look, here's why I think I've come around a little bit. I was very militant five or six seasons ago about how I thought we should behave in the market. And I feel not justified, but I feel that I had a reason for that militance in my perspective, which is you have to start doing the right things to get back to where we wanted to be. You can't keep doing dumb things, thinking short term. You have to have some vision of building for the future. And we did. We started buying players pre-prime and they started to age into their primes together. And we continued to do that so that when we hit a winning window, all our players were prime and it worked. But Kayo Saka's in his prime, Kai Havertz, Declan Rice, Zubimendi, Odegaard, Saliba, Gabby.
Elliot Smith32:06Timber, Cal Fiorian and Hincapié on the younger side, but they're also like all these players, David Riot, they're all in the heart of their prime right now. Now, some of them have been more important than we thought, some maybe less important than we thought. Whatever the case may be. And so there is a need to backfill, of course. Now you could we're backfilling with Max, maybe with Ethan if he stays. We're backfilling with Myles Lewis-Skelly. And maybe a Tzolis comes in. You we want a Jeremy Manga. There there are there are things that we could be doing. To backfill for the development. But when you're in your winning window, your primary concern has to be extending it. It cannot be what do we if we spent this window worrying about what do we do when Rice is done, when Saliba's done, when Gabby's done, when Saka's done. First of all, that wouldn't be fair to those players who are here now and want to keep winning. And second of all, you have no ability to understand what that rebuild's gonna look like at this time. So I think this is the right thing. In in that respect. But here's the other thing I think I've come around to learning. My theory that you have to buy young and find those values in the market and then develop them. And then you have resale value. What's the theory there? All right, you buy a good player, you buy a good player for 30 million at 22. They're good. And they're developing. And by 26, they've developed into a really great player. So you sell them? Well,
Elliot Smith33:28That that doesn't help you. Or you buy, you buy a 22-year-old for 30 million, good value, bargain, he doesn't really turn out to be very good. What are you gonna get for him? Well, what did we get for Sambi? What did we get for Fabio Vieira? So you go one of two directions. You buy a player with the hope that they're elite, and if they're elite, you don't want to lose them. Or you buy a player that never develops into an elite player, and you're not getting any money for them because nobody wants them and you have them on Premier League wages. So i to me, I get it. Do you want to buy a bunch of players who are aging out of their prime and have absolutely no resale value? No, you can't build a whole squad that way. But I think that you cannot be militant about avoiding those players. Adam Vogue posted on Blue Sky, said I was just playing with the formula, and here are the transfer age midfielders who are within a reasonable distance of Bruno in creativity, progression, and out of possession value added. These are the names. Angelo Stiller, I think a fascinating player, by the way, but coming from the Bundesliga, unclear what you get. Adam Morton. Hundred million if you can get him at all or more, and you have the out-of-possession question, of course. James Garner, who's a fascinating player to me. He shows up great on data. People rate him. He's at Everton, though. Is the Sean Dych system causing some things to look more progressive? I don't know. Great player, very interesting. Kodai Sano, who we've seen at the World Cup, and Luciano Valente. Those last two are I think, punts on value and hope. That's not the area we're in right now. So for me, looking at that list.
Elliot Smith34:55Bruno feels like value. I wanna I want to do this, Tim. I want to talk about who he's gonna play with, how you see it impacting the rest of the squad, because we start to look like we have a big midfield group. And I want to get your thoughts on that. We can talk a little bit about Meslier as well, and then get out of here. So let me, before we talk about why this is the end of Zubimendi's Arsenal career forever, I'm kidding. I'm kidding, it isn't. It's the end of Oda Gar. No, I'm kidding. It's not. It's the end of Ethan. No! Elliot, stop. When you're at the bottom of the hole, stop digging. That's the first way out. Tim, whose career is over with Bruno coming? I'm kidding, but I'm not because like see, this is the thing. I couldn't Nor Norgard's career is over. Okay.
Tim Stillman35:29Well, Norgard, that's.
Elliot Smith35:34See, I couldn't pin Clive down, but I feel that I can pin you down to have an opinion here. Th the reality is, as much as Clive will scream at me, and that's fine. I can take that. I can't. I'll be terrified. There is in there tends to be a group that a manager picks most often. And that group tends to reflect the players that he really feels can do what he needs them to do. Declan Rice gets picked, every game is fit. If Pikayo Sak was fit, he'd get picked every game, right? Saliba Gabby, they get picked every game. Timber, if he's fit or not fit, gets picked every game. Right. There are certain players that get rotated, but in general, there are certain players that don't. I'm really fascinated with what you think the midfield looks like with Bruno Guimarães. My instinct, with the way Myles looked, he'll be in the plan this season. I think Zubimendi's reputation has taken too big a hit. More of a hit than it deserves because he had a weak end to the season. Interesting, by the way, he's not even getting on the pitch for Spain this summer. I think he just needed a refresh. He's getting it, so he's gonna be nice and fresh. I think he was very impactful in the start of the season, and we've forgotten that. But it's Rice, Bruno, Zubi, Myles. That's the group for that area midfield. And I'm curious how you think that group looks from a I don't want to say pecking order standpoint, but from the how the pieces get together. And if it is Rice and Bruno,
Elliot Smith36:55Who you think the third piece is that complements that group best? What's the alchemy there?
Tim Stillman37:01Yeah, so I think that third piece will rotate a little bit. I think probably mainly Odegaard. I still think that in its heart of hearts, Artetto prefers Odegaard there than Eze, but it might change a little bit from game to game. I think also what we, a tough lesson we've had to learn over the last two seasons is what we look like without some of our best players. So when I was writing something today about Bruno Morgan Rogers and fixing progressive passing and all of that I did have to make the point a lot of these numbers are down because Sacka was injured and Havertz was injured and Odegaard was injured and actually if you just bring those guys back all of those numbers will boost right the probably won't boost us to the highest progressive passes, but we're We'd get we'd get out of eighth place in that particular metric but where we've been fortunate, and this relates to both of the transfer conversations we're going to have in this episode, where we've been fortunate, we haven't had to on a long term basis glimpse what Arsenal looks like without Declan Rice because he's been fit the whole time he's been here pretty much. And we haven't had to glimpse what Arsenal looked like without David Ryre for too long either, albeit we did get a little bit of a glimpse.
Tim Stillman38:23In some of the cup competitions last season. There are some things we've gotten away with, it has to be said. Were without Saliba and Gabriel for a couple of games last season around Chelsea away, Villa away and we didn't look good. Surprise, surprise. So what we've had to do by force is build some Sackalus, Urdagardless, Havertz-less contingency. We haven't had to do that for Declan Rice yet, but it's come, it will come. He's, he's not going to stay fit forever. That, that will come. And if it's going to come, it's going to come off the back of the world cup year, most likely where he's playing with ice packs on his, on his hamstrings and all of that. So there's that part of it. And I do think that that is a big part of it, that they are probably thinking like this Rice Fitness run is not going to last forever. However, I do see it being Rice and Guimarães as the kind of two, because what was interesting about Rice and Zubimendi as well, and before Zubimendi got really knackered, and this is where we missed Moreno as well, I really think he could have taken some of that burden and we've got to factor him hopefully back into the equation as well. But I think
Tim Stillman39:48Rice and Zubimendi was a very, it was like a rotating double pivot. Wasn't like, Thomas Partey or Giorginio sits here and Rice goes there. It was much more fluid than that. And actually I think a bit of that fluidity broke down and it did start to look like two guys standing in front of the centre backs, passing side to side a little bit. But I had, I went on, the La Grove podcast with Jacob, who's been on this podcast a few times and does his own non football podcast, which is amazing by the way, Screen Rot. But one of the things they do in the show, which I'm surprised you don't do actually, is like they force you to do a hot take. What's your hot take that you really wouldn't want to share? And my hot, this was early June. My hot take was that Lewis-Skelly was in midfield to stay. He'd get ahead of Subramendi in the pecking order. Not because I necessarily think he's a better player or Subramendi's no good, just because he offers progression in a different way. He dribbles, but he offers progression and he's a really good partner for Rice. But if we're buying Guimarães, obviously I'd throw that hot take in the bin. I don't think we'd be spending big money on a 28 year old for him to be a rotation option, to be honest. Whereas when we bought Mikel Merino,
Tim Stillman41:09That number, because we bought him at 28, didn't we? That number, that price was a bit more, we really like you, we think you can fill in a number of ways. One of them ended up being upfront, but probably you're not in the Champions League final starting lineup type thing. Whereas Guimarães, I think that number is going to be, you're going to be a regular starter for us. And if we're going to push for a player like this and all of the hassle that I think is going to come with that as well. I think it's for no other reason than this guy will be seen as a starter and Zubimendi might fall into that Merino category, which by the way is still incredibly important. He will play a lot of football. It would hopefully be one of those things where, big whoop Zubimendi starts instead of Rice or Guimarães, no one talks about it type thing. Bit I think on a slightly level like what we've had with Martinelli and Trossard It's like ultimately who cares which one of those players starts. They're both on a very similar level They just do different things So I think that's where we'll get to with Zubimendi still a really important player But maybe not the this guy plays every game type player anymore
Elliot Smith42:30Yeah, I think this should be a safe space for being honest, and I'll be honest, I think Bruno Guimarães a better player than Zubimendi. I Zubimendi's a good player. It it is unfortunate that the way we discuss players is they're shit or they're great. And there's no nuance or range other than that. I think Zubimendi is a good player. I think Bruno Guimarães is an elite Premier League level midfielder. And I think he adds a lot of things that we could use. The thing that surprised me Zubimendi, and I noticed it even in the in the scouting video, but we do profile players a little bit about what we expect that they are. And they're they're not always that thing. Zubimendi is not a high pass volume, high pass percentage metronome. He's not a super progressive passer from central midfield. I think he's actually a great presser, a great recover of the ball up the pitch. And I think he's good in the final third, interestingly, or on the end of moves. He's he's more merino than he is Jorginho. Let's put it that way.
Elliot Smith43:30What I mean? But I look at the group, and the group starts to look very robust, to put it mildly. And and another way you could put it is crowded. Because you have Zubi, Bruno, if we get him. Zubi, Bruno, Rice, Myles, Merino, Kai, Odegaard, Eze, Max, Ethan, if you want to throw them in there, and maybe a Morgan Rogers. And I think that everybody who watches Arsenal at all agrees on one thing. Arsenal have to find a way to create more chances and score more goals from open play. And I don't think you get there with a functional controlling midfield. I don't know that I believe that. Now, maybe you get a healthy Saka and you put someone really talented on the left wing and you go, surprise, surprise, better attackers makes your attack better. That could well be the case. I think Saka's situation has made life really tricky for us. Really, really tricky. And we need, look, there's only one Bukayo Saka in world football. Liverpool aren't going to find another Muhammad Salah, certainly not easily. City wouldn't be able to replace Erling Haaland. We can't replace what Saka gives us when he's at his best. So I acknowledge that some degree of decline in our attacking capacity comes from our best player and one of the best right wingers in all of football not being at his best and not being available.
Elliot Smith44:58If he is, that will improve things. And if we get someone better off the left, that'll improve things. I think that the question of if it's Bruno and Rice, let's just say I hate the word first choice because I know people will throw up on that. But if that's the two of the three midfielders we're picking a lot, I think the question of what the third midfielder looks like is really interesting. Is it a technical between the lines final third demon like Ebracha Eze? Is it a possession monster like Martin Odegaard? Is it an off ball physical player like a Kai or a Merino? Is it a transition monster like a Morgan Rogers? You could say, yes, it's all of those things and it's whatever you need. I believe that Martin Odegaard is aging into being more 6'8 than 8 10. It's interesting. The Norway coach, I think his name is Sobakin was saying we don't play Odegaard as a 10. At Norway. We don't. That's not how we use him. Look, I'd that's not how
Tim Stillman46:00And he was saying that's not how Arsenal use him either.
Elliot Smith46:02Our yeah, I'd like to be as honest as I can be about Martin Odegaard. I think Martin Odegaard is just fundamentally not the player he was of before the ankle injury. This is a player who was 20 to 25 plus goal involvements. And you can't take that away and say he's the identical player. That's not me saying I don't rate him. But if you have a midfielder who was a twenty to twenty five goal involvement player, arguably one of our best shooters and finishers, really, legitimately, the way he struck the ball. And great with the final ball in the final third. If you have that player who is also one of the best ball progressors and possession players, you have one of the best midfielders in world football. If you take the goal involvements away, you still have one of the great possession-oriented midfielders in football. But now you have to ask what else they add. And I would just say for the people that are like, look at the hundred passes he did against Brazil. Look, we had Martin Odegaard on the pitch against PSG, and we couldn't get close to the ball. So the idea that Martin Odegaard solves our problem in the highest level games of needing to be on the ball just isn't the case. So then the question is, what is his role? And my belief is his role is more 6'8 than 8'10. And then if you want to play Rice and Odegaard and Eze, I love If you want to play Rice and Odegaard and Rogers or Rice and Audegaard and Reno, I think that can work. I think if you play Rice and Bruno and Odegaard, that would be really interesting. I would love to see if that would help Martin get some of the goals and assists back, get some of the end product back.
Elliot Smith47:22Because if we're gonna be fair to Saka and say he just hasn't been fit for a while now, we should be fair to Odegaard and say maybe he's just getting back to fitness and we will start to see some of that end product in his game. To me, the reason Odegaard is a big talking point is he is our captain. He's one of our highest earners, he has two years left on his deal. So are you going to invest another 285 a week, 250 a week? That's what it's gonna cost to renew him. Are you gonna let him get to a one year left on his deal? Because he's a globally important player. He has value. Are you going to build around him? And do you believe that his fitness level is such that he can be at the at his best? Tim, these are not questions we should shy away from due to tribalism or polarization of a debate. We should be able to discuss what the right way to continue to use and benefit from Martin Odegaard is with thoughtfulness about where he is in his contract term, with thoughtfulness about how his game is evolving and the degree to which we think his fitness might help him get some of those goals and assists back and how he fits into what becomes a crowded midfield if we bring in Bruno and Morgan Rogers, and you still merino and Kai and Ethan and Max and Myles and so I'm I'm curious how you think of this in terms of Odegaard. Clearly one of the still important big midfield players in the game, but what's the fit?
Elliot Smith48:45For our midfield dynamic. I just I it is a question that is fascinating to me and I think there's scope for having it a positive way a and I just don't see a lot of that unfortunately.
Tim Stillman48:55Yeah, yeah. No, I agree. I think it's fascinating as well. Not least because we're not hearing anything about contract talks, right? And that suggests that that's a question for Arteta and the staff, right? Otherwise, maybe it's happening and we just don't know about it. That feels unlikely to me. Yeah.
Elliot Smith49:13Twenty twenty eight, right? So am I right in saying that's two more ye right, it's not it doesn't expire in twenty seven, it expires in twenty eight. Yeah, so two years. So this would be the time that you'd start to think about a renewal or something like that. Yeah.
Tim Stillman49:23Yeah, and look, maybe, the transfer window is not the best time to do it. Maybe the day after deadline, they will hear and now they will move on some contracts or not, but not really hearing any noises around it, which suggests to me and similar with haverts as well. And that to me has to be a physical question, a question of style or anything else. But I do think it's fascinating. I think that I think the other thing that's really interesting, right? So Bruno and Rogers, they seem to be the big targets, right? And you pull up the data, they get the ball into the final third. They do it in different ways, but they get the ball into final third. Morgan Rogers rates very highly for through balls. He's a risk taker with the ball. I think people have a very narrow definition of what creativity entails. I think people think. Has to be Burkamp Fabregas-Ursel. That's the only creativity that exists in football. And again, to create a really crude example, I remember having an argument with someone years ago, because I think Peter Crouch came second in the Premier League for assists when he was playing for Stoke. How do you think he got those assists? Peter Crouch playing for Stoke? You can probably guess, right? Flicking on long balls, right? And so someone
Elliot Smith50:39Mm. Yeah. Route one. Mm-hmm.
Tim Stillman50:44Was like, does that make Peter Crouch creative player? And I was like, yes. Yes, it literally does. He is literally creating loads and loads of chances. He's just doing it in a slightly different way. And I won't waste anyone's time with I think a lot of the aesthetic argument, I think a lot of that is dogma. Actually, I think it's just you are told that aesthetics have, there is one good way to do aesthetics and blah, blah, blah. You are told that. Footballers are only creative if they're doing flicks and tricks and through balls and stuff like that I think a lot of that is assumed knowledge that is almost like It's like the right way to play football and the only way to do that is lots of short passes and all of that But there are other ways of being creative and I think it's really interesting that Bruno again potentially because of maybe the way he's played against Arsenal Which would be a very different challenge for new cast and a lot of their games a lot of people think of him as a shin kicker and I think he can do that. Don't get me wrong. That's not who he is. No, no, he is. Yeah, he's
Elliot Smith51:48It's in his game, but that's not that's not how he's defined at all. He's such a technical player.
Tim Stillman51:53Hugely technical. He's a progressive passer and, and so but he doesn't fit our idea of that. And it's the same with Morgan Rogers. I think he is a creative player in a very different way. He makes stuff happen. He doesn't do it in the UrdaGuard way by having 300 touches a game. So there are different types of creativity going on here and UrdaGuard is one of them. And there are games where we really need that. I won't go back and relitigate the Everton game again, because everyone's heard me do that 50 times, but where we doubled our passing average for the season away at Everton. Because what did we want to do? We wanted to keep the ball on the floor the whole time and have no transitions and no fouls and stuff. So what do you need? UrdaGuard for that. Do think it's developing into a very kind of horses for courses. We can see that center forward have us in your cares. We can see that on the wings. There are very different profiles of player and I really think that our Teta has wanted for a long time to move to and I think he's got there largely that I want to be able to solve every problem. Now I think some people would say but do we have enough of the Urda guard type creativity?
Tim Stillman53:10Do we have enough of that? Because it does feel like we've got a lot of almost brute force, in that respect. And I think that's that's a fair question. However, with Erdogan, the fact that I'm not really hearing anything about a contract, that does make me wonder a little bit if they're just going to wait and see. And again, that might be a physical question as well. It might be. I would if I were asked and I'd be like, you know what? We've had two seasons that have been quite on off because of injury, your form's been up and down. We're not going to give you 285 grand a week yet into your early thirties. We can't make that decision yet. Maybe three, four months into next season, they feel like they can, but I think that's an open question. I really do. And I can only deduce that it's an open question for the club as well.
Elliot Smith54:02Yeah. Yeah. Everybody has their conception of the right way to play football, to create chances. They have things that fit their eye. Cl Yeah.
Tim Stillman54:15And we want to do every way. I think that's the thing.
Elliot Smith54:17Yeah. And and Clive and I talk about this a lot, right? This kind of player that he really is drawn to, that kind of player that I'm really drawn to. Everybody knows Ebert Che Eze is that kind of player that I just kinda like those fantasy players, good in tight spaces, really technical, can see a pass no one else sees or score a goal no one else scores. But I will be the first to acknowledge that Ebracha Ezo was less influential than I expected in his first season at Arsenal, that it was not the season I fully expected from him. Go ahead, yeah.
Tim Stillman54:44Yeah, was going to say I'm like an Aaron Ramsey, Alexis Sanchez guy, guys that they might cough up the ball. Yeah, they might cough up the ball. They
Elliot Smith54:48Yeah. All action. Mm.
Tim Stillman54:53Might take some shots that make you kick your chair and swear, but they do stuff. They get stuff done. I like risk takers, but you can't have too many of those. Otherwise you're turning the ball over all of the time. You do you ultimately, whatever your aesthetic preference is, you do have to have a bit of everything.
Elliot Smith55:15It's funny, I was gonna say, I don't know that we have a player like you just described currently. Rice can be a bit of that, but the closest I can think of it in attack is ironically Noni Madueke. He tries and tries and tries and tries, but unlike Alexis Sanchez or Aaron Ramsey, it doesn't come off maybe as much a as you'd like.
Tim Stillman55:30Yeah, and maybe that's who Morgan Rogers would be as well.
Elliot Smith55:34That's I was just gonna say that. Yeah, I do think if you have Bruno Morgan Rogers and Declan Rice in your team, especially if you have Akai Havertz in your team, you are building one of the fearsome transition teams in world football. The ability to win the ball back and turn ball recovery into goal, I think becomes just unrivaled, especially if you have Bukayo Saka back to his best with his burst. And we are gonna have to accept that Saka, Odegaard, Rice Saliba, Timber. There's a lot of players with lingering long-term medical issues that their recovery from those issues will determine to some extent our ceiling for this season. Now, with Rice, I will tell you I am less concerned than others about Rice, who seem to think he's got some major back problem. The way it's being described, it sounds more like sciatica, which is just, first of all, it's a pain tolerance thing. But second of all, you can get that pinching to stop. And if that pinching stops, then you're fine. It's not a muscular issue. Now, like any injury, pain can cause you to change how you run or change how you move, and that can lead to lots of injuries. Saka, yeah, you gotta be worried. You gotta be worried a little bit, because it's a long-term ankle injury, and the only thing that fixes it is probably just a lot of rest. It's not a case of, we do this procedure and then you're fine. S from what we understand, Saliba needs a minor back procedure. Scary because it's his back, but if it fixes it, so be it. Saka, there doesn't seem to be a clear path. Not gonna do the whole medical thing now, but some of what we're probably trying to do is make sure that we have redundancies.
Elliot Smith57:01Because the brutality of and the attritional quality of the football calendar means the teams that win are the teams that are fit at the end of the season. You can do that one of two ways. You can be PSG and play in a league that is not competitive for you. And so your best players are just Champions League pieces that you roll out for the games that matter, and then you roll back in the garage and they sit there. L like a nice car in the summer. I live in Minneapolis and Minnesota. And the wealthy people here have their pretty cars and they only come out in the summer, right? They're in the garage the whole winter, so they don't get the snow and the salt and the dirt on them. It must be nice. But but the fact is that's what PSG can do. We can't do that. So then the way you go about doing it is you just have redundancies. And it does seem like we have a lot of redundancy in a lot of positions now that could be very and I say now we don't have Bruno, we don't have Rogers, we haven't signed anyone but Ilan Mellier, who
Tim Stillman57:53Yeah, yeah. But it's what we're trying to do,
Elliot Smith57:55We've officially signed. Yeah, so that's what we're trying to do. As we as we wrap on this, I think the reason I find the Odegaard piece so interesting is identity, right? If you think about the identity of this team through the eras Mikel being at the club, I think Martin Odegaard has been the rare bridge between those eras. We had we had Odegaard th through it all mostly. We've moved on from some of the other players that were key pieces, Jesus and Zinchenko and you Ben White, I think, is, at the at the end there, and players that we really identify with those first phases, Shaka. But Odegaard has been there. And the thing about Odegaard is he's he's such a big presence in your team when he plays, and understanding his role and what that will look like moving forward, I think, is interesting. But I'm in this weird between two.
Elliot Smith58:56Stalls thing where I think he's still way too good not to find a role for him. But I think if the end product isn't what it was once if it's if that's not going to come back, then I think he's not necessarily a horse for every course. He's not necessarily and the question is, with two years left on his deal and it going on twenty eight years old, is that what he wants? 'Cause this is the interesting thing. The debate around Bruno is is he too old to be acquiring now? Odegaard's one year younger. Right? He's one year younger. He'll be twenty-eight this season. So he's very much in his prime, but he probably has one more big contract left. Where does he want that to be? We'll see. Final thing here. Illan Mellier officially announced by Arsenal. Does that make him our first signing of the summer? I guess. Yeah. Our first big signing of the summer. That'll get everybody fired up. I'm sure the comments under the Twitter post were rational and cool headed. But I'll ask you, Tim, do you have any opinion on this. I find myself unable to have any opinion other than fine. If our team of talent developers and talent identifiers thinks he's acceptable to be our third or second choice goalkeeper, then who am I to argue? We've got David Raya, Setford will go out on loan and develop. And, Kepp is a big name, talented, experienced keeper. He was our backup last season. We used him twice. He cost us two truck, two cups. So
Elliot Smith1:00:20You can do all the right things. You can buy a backup who's experienced and talented and everybody rates him. And he can th chuck two cups for you. So who the heck knows what to make a Melier?
Tim Stillman1:00:31Yeah. First off, it looks like he's going to be the third goalkeeper and, in that scenario, Noah. Yeah, exactly. In that scenario. No, I have no opinion at all.
Elliot Smith1:00:36If KEPA stays. Mm-hmm. No opinion whatsoever.
Tim Stillman1:00:42And usually in training, I think the idea is you want four cause they pair off quite a lot. Right. So you want four competent goalkeepers to be able to do that. As part of the training group, I think the thing is, on backup goalkeepers, you can't win. You can't win because one of two things happens. I think Kepper is an unusually high standard second choice goalkeeper. Unusually. I think you don't usually get one like that. And obviously the position turns over a lot. So you have this conversation a lot, but it goes in phases, right? We had Leno as our backup goalkeeper when we bought Ramsdale. Obviously that lost one season because he's too good to be a backup. We had Ramsdale as a backup for one season. Same thing happened there. And then you have these kind of in between goalkeepers, a bit like Matt Turner and, potentially Kepper at the moment. The problem and so obviously it's a very difficult position to buy. It's going to be the position where you've got the biggest delta between your first and second choice, because good goalkeepers don't really tend to want to do that job. And even if you get one, you don't for long.
Tim Stillman1:01:54Again, I was talking earlier about how we've probably been quite lucky in some respects injury wise. This is a position where we've been lucky. Like Neto. Rubbish, but Ryre stayed fit, so he didn't have to play, didn't matter. Roonison, rubbish. He cost us a League Cup game against Man City that we were lost anyway, so who cares? And he cost £1 million, genuinely, who cares? And then so
Elliot Smith1:02:19They should have given me that one million pounds. Yeah. Come on. I could have done better.
Tim Stillman1:02:25What we haven't had a significant goalkeeper injury for a while, except the last time it happened was when we were in that rare sweet spot, was when it happened to Leno and Martinez was our backup goalkeeper at that point. And he came in and created a genuine conversation around who we should keep. And now he's Aston Villa's number one, he's Argentina's number one. So the last time we were genuinely exposed in that position, we had a really, really good backup. But what happened? He played 10 games and he left because he was like, I'm too good to do this. The other problem it gives you, I know people will be saying, why are you saying Kepa's good after what happened last season? Here's the other problem. No matter how good your second choice goalkeeper is, when they play once every two months, they will be crap anyway, right? The same thing happened to Ramsdale. Ramsdale was a perfectly good goalkeeper for Arsenal. He spent one season on the bench, but he had to play those games against Brentford because of the loan agreement. What happened?
Tim Stillman1:03:28He chucked one in his net. Right? And why did he do that? That wasn't standard for him. He did that because he played three games that season and he wasn't sharp. It's the same with Kepper. If Kepper had been playing for three months before that Carabao Cup final, I guarantee you that mistake doesn't happen. Same in the FA Cup. I guarantee you those mistakes do not happen. They happen because he's playing infrequently. So whoever your backup goalkeeper is, they're going to play below their level anyway, unless you get genuinely exposed and your goalkeeper's out for six months or something. At which point, if that happened to us, that would be terrible and it be very, very costly. But I bet Keppel would look fine over six months if we had to do it like. He wouldn't be as good as David Raya, of course not, but I bet he'd largely be fine. I bet he wouldn't be doing like, chucking the ball in his own net every game. Might happen once a month or something, because he's not at the standard of Raya. But that's why, as a position, it's almost impossible. And any situation you get where you have a really good second choice is temporary. People point to Kelleher at Liverpool. What happened?
Tim Stillman1:04:42He went to Brentford. He got sick of being the backup at Liverpool and rightly so, cause he's quite good. I just think these things, it's almost, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Elliot Smith1:04:49Yeah, th they invested in Marmadashvili, right? And but didn't bring him didn't bring him in because they knew they couldn't keep him happy as a backup, so
Tim Stillman1:04:57Exactly, exactly. So you get very rare spots of sunlight where you hit a bit of a sweet spot, but it's temporary anyway. So, yeah.
Elliot Smith1:05:06I think we should leave it there. I wanna say though, links with Christos Tzolis have picked up again, and Tzolis is a player that we did scout. And I will simply say, low key, I think if he comes in, I think he's gonna be a bit of a favorite. I think he's a really, really talented player. And, there are things that don't scale to leagues. We've seen with Yokar S there were growing pains in coming from the Portuguese league where he could physically, destroy the opposition. To Premier League where couldn't with his athleticism and his and his power, but Tzolis' technical level is high. He has two feet, which I know you'll loved him. Unlike Endrick, who tried to take that 1v1 with his left and was so in intent on getting it on his left that he missed for Brazil. Tzolis has two feet, and he does the thing that I think Martin Elliot is best does, but hasn't done as much lately, which is quick first time decision. Cut in, curl it on his right. Or beat the man with one step and fired him with his left. He has an eye for a pass. He destroyed the league he was in, which is a good sign, right? The the numbers, I think it was twenty-nine assists or goals or something. It was it was twenty, twenty-two and four seventeen, something insane, but it's not the output. It was watching him smart, technical, two footed. I think as a Leo analog, I see it.
Elliot Smith1:06:28But he's quicker than I expected. I think he can still run away from people a little bit, just enough to be dangerous. And assuming that we get someone that we think is the first choice off the left, I think he's a tremendous high-level squad player to invest in at a low cost. So I'd be very excited to get that done because I think we may need to be replacing both our left-wide options and that I wouldn't have sold Leo. Candidly, I wouldn't have sold Leo. I would have kept him. I would have invested big in the younger star left-wing signing. I understand Leo probably wants to go to three years on a last deal in his prime, so it makes sense for the player. But if we're gonna sell him, I like Soli's Tim, so I'm excited to see him if we get him.
Tim Stillman1:07:05Yeah, yeah, I think there's a, to tie all of this together, there's some, there's some other things here. So this is a young man's position, I think. So we're talking about Bruno, central midfield, not really a place for kids. All right, Myles, I've bigged him up, so fair enough, but.
Elliot Smith1:07:22Well look at Ethan, a sensational player, but when he was moved inside i you could see the growing pains, it's harder. Mm-hmm.
Tim Stillman1:07:27Yeah. On the outside, though, we brought Saka into the team at 18, 19. We brought Martin, Martin Ellion. Madareke is only what 22, 23. It's more of a young man's position than maybe some of those spinal positions. But also, and going back to our conversation earlier, I don't think we'll do this deal if we do it, because it's like we're investing in, there'll be an element of we're investing in a younger player for the longer term, because we're effectively replacing a 31 year old. You 24, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So
Elliot Smith1:07:57He is twenty four, I should say, by the way. So n we're not yeah, not a not a child person, He's coming into his prime.
Tim Stillman1:08:03Yeah, exactly. What are we looking at for attacking positions? Rogers and this guy are both 23, 24. Whereas Bruno's 28. So that tells you a story, but I think there's two parts of it. There is a value part of it. This really upset this before this. Feels and sounds a bit like the guy that Brentford or Bournemouth or Brighton buy and two seasons later they sell to you for 80 million. It has that feel to it but also I think that they're probably going to do it because they want Rogers as well and in this price range they could they think they can do both or there's a reasonable expectation that they can do both so it might be a bit of a punt in terms of the level and everything like that. But I do think there's an economic reality behind it, which is we want Morgan Rodgers. He might cost nine figures and we need another guy. So, yeah, we do have to shop into in that 30, 35 million bracket. So I think there's an element of that to it as well. It's budgeting kind of thing. But I don't know enough about the player. But obviously, if you lose Leo Trossard,
Tim Stillman1:09:17We're trying to score more goals as well. And I appreciate Trossard didn't have his most prolific season last season, but we're trying to score 15, 20 more goals and we're probably going to lose one of our most reliable goal scorers. So that has to be replaced. You can't just say the 20 million for Trossard looks nice on the balance sheet. You have to go and get replaced that end product. Yeah, but overall this strikes me as the buy some Enyo from, was it Sunderland? I think some years, buying from Sunderland instead of from Bournemouth type thing.
Elliot Smith1:09:54Literally, if Tzolis can get a third of the goals and assists, a quarter of the goals and assists he got this past season, it will have probably been a good return. I agree with you on all that, Tim, and I will say as a as a final, final, final thing. If we get the players we're linked with, I'd probably hold on tight for maybe one big departure that we don't expect. And I'm not gonna sit here and pretend I know who it is. I don't know if it's a Kai or an Odegaard or S someone. So yeah and as a Zubimendi again, I know all of that sounds ridiculous. We just got two of those guys. They're not leaving. But my point is certain areas start to feel crowded when Bruno and Rogers get in. The one that unfortunately to me looks like it makes sense because you'd get good money for him and there isn't room is Ethan, which would be a real shame because the talent I think is too big to let go of. But like I said, you can't and this is the thing we're gonna have to get comfortable with as a big club. As a club competing to win the league and the Champions League every season, season in, season out. When you are trying to stay forth, you don't have a squad like we have now, so you have room to make way for young, talented players. When
Elliot Smith1:11:05You are trying to win the biggest trophies every single season, inevitably someone who's good will be on the outside looking in and not want to stay. And you have to get comfortable with that. You do. It's unfortunate. But it's the case, and we'll just see how that shakes out. Okay. Friday Night Club tomorrow. World Cup Daily comes back. Excited for the World Cup to come back today. As France and Morocco play should be a fantastic game. So looking forward to that. Tim, thank you very much.
Tim Stillman1:11:31My pleasure as always.
Elliot Smith1:11:32We will have details of the Dublin event soon. So want to get that out to you soon. We'll talk to Andrew and we'll confirm it. But there's going to be an event in Dublin, I believe the day before the game, the preseason game there. Talking about preseason already. Jeez. Never ends. Watch the football. Watch it. It's always on. Okay, we love you. And we will talk to you for Arsenal 10.