EpisodesThe Main PodSeason 2026/27

Fallout From The Premier League’s Statement on Manchester City

Episode 1038 · · Elliot with Tim

0:0050:56

DownloadOr listen in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Pocket Casts, the AVP app or RSS

Show notes

On this edition of the ArsenalVision Podcast, Elliot is joined by Tim to discuss all the ramifications of the Premiere League’s statement on the Manchester City case, City’s reaction, and where it goes from here.

Shopify: You put in the work. Time to get paid like it. Get a free trial at shopify.com/arsenalvision

Original theme music by Paul Hepker

Chapters

Tap a chapter to play from there.

Watch it

Transcript

It's automatic, so expect the odd misheard word. Ads in the audio can make it run a minute or two later than the times shown.

Read the transcript

Elliot Smith0:26Look, I was pretty sure that the Premier League had City dead to rights, but SkyBlue7542 on Twitter says he's looked at the documents and there's lots of holes in the case. This is the ArsenalVision Podcast. My name is Alex Bot Military King's Gunner. That's right. Sky Blues everywhere have become legal experts. They've looked at the case, they've seen the numbers, they've looked at the documents. Case is riddled with holes, riddled with holes. I realize 7,000 documents, tens of witnesses, hundreds of hours of testimony, years of reviewing it, a panel of three. Experts with judicial backgrounds. They looked at it. They just didn't see what sky blue champions forty-seven forty-seven underscore Bob on Twitter saw. And that omission is going to be fatal to their case. We'll see. We're going to talk about the Premier League's statement, Manchester City's inevitable influence campaign response, where we go from here. Might touch on a little football, but honestly, I think for today we'll just stay on this. We've got next week to get back into the football. Some things coming up. Will Balsam is gonna come on next week and talk about the Academy. So we're gonna have a pod on some of the players that you know have been in the news, El Shavuna, the Quintero twins, Batrashvili, maybe a bit on Ethan's loan, but also some of the Academy kids that you know. You know, Marley Salmon, Harriman Anous, we'll get into that, Ife Ibrahim. So that'll be out next week. Matt Giant Gunnar will do some stuff on Chelsea's finances because let's not forget the original, the OG frauds.

Elliot Smith1:54Do some weird shit. The debt crisis in football. We'll talk about all that. There really isn't any football to talk about, just finance stuff. So all that'll be out next week. Phil will be hosting pods next week as well, as I hope to be away. Although today I've discovered that I have pneumonia. So it's all going great. It's all going so, so good. So good. But I am still enjoying Manchester City's plight and I will be updating you on my health as I get more on that. Okay, Champions Fifty is the code if you wanna get to Patreon and get all that good stuff I just mentioned. If you don't, we're just happy you're here. Really love you. Thanks for being here. Honestly, you're the best. Tim, welcome.

Tim Stillman2:29I like that.

Elliot Smith2:29How you doing?

Tim Stillman2:30Yeah, good, thank you, good.

Elliot Smith2:32You're bathed in sunlight. The the truth shall set you free. Sunlight is the is the greatest anti antiseptic. Is is that what this is? This is an analogy for the Manchester City's

Tim Stillman2:40It yeah, yeah.

Elliot Smith2:41Crimes being dragged into the light?

Tim Stillman2:43It's literally it's j it's just coming through my curtains and it's it's impenetrable. The curtains are pretty firmly closed, but yeah, it's it's almost like the sun is sitting directly outside my window. It's quite nice actually.

Elliot Smith2:57That is nice. Your your country is not known for that regularly, so take it while you can. All right. I spoke to Clive and Phil the moment the Premier League ruling came out and statement came out. They've had some time to digest it. And I really want to break this conversation into two things. What the Premier League said and the implications of it, and then Manchester City's inevitable influence campaign response and intimidation campaign response. And so let's let's start with the league statement. Were you surprised at how quickly it came out and how forceful it was.

Tim Stillman3:31So how quickly it came out, n no, not necessarily. I've been listening a lot to the athletic podcast. They are quite rightly getting a lot of mileage out of this, in terms of their audio output because

Elliot Smith3:44Gonna summarize most of what they said so you don't have to go listen to them. You c just stay here. We got you covered. Sorry, keep going.

Tim Stillman3:48Their journalists broke the story and they actually did a very interesting pod David Ornstein did on the actual process of breaking that story. But listening to that it was clear that it was like it was coming out soon and actually a lot of people had started to hear something might drop. What we last Friday. But actually I've listened to quite a number of journalists this week who are like, I've just heard that so many times over the last three years that I didn't know whether to take it. It seriously but I think a mixture of Matt Slater and David Ornstein got the drop on the athletic so it was quite clear that they'd got the tip off very close to this coming out. I think there's there's a couple of things that are really interesting. The Premier League did not respond immediately that the story broke which tells me they were when did they release the statement? Tuesday or Wednesday? Tuesday yeah

Elliot Smith4:40Tuesday. Yeah, Tuesday.

Tim Stillman4:42That tells me they always had that day slated to release that statement. And when the report came out, they were not minded to change it. That that tells me that they had their ducks in a row. This was very concerted. And you know, for nothing to come out when you piece this together, it sounds like Man City were told in the summer and early in the summer, and the clubs all have to sign NDAs about this kind of stuff. But like, this hasn't come out for basically it sounds like this has been kicking around for a few months and it hadn't come out till now. Basically and again that tells you about the Premier League's approach to this. There were no leaks whatsoever about the Chargers in twenty three. That came directly from the Premier League. No one had that. And basically David Ornstein, who has a reputation you know, for being one of the finest kind of sports journalists in the world, possibly. And I'm not across other sports so I don't know. But like

Tim Stillman5:45He gets it a couple of days before. And and it's clear quite a lot of people know. I think that tells you the level of secrecy, and the secrecy usually spells up to seriousness. So it tells me that the Premier League were always going to release that statement on that day, and they were not minded to change when the reports came out. And they didn't really respond to the reports, which tells you that they were brilliantly sourced and very, very accurate as it's turned out. So I guess it was only a matter of time before the Premier League were gonna say something. And I always felt that they weren't gonna leave a void there for too long. So I was expecting them to say something kind of any time now. Now, in terms of what they've said, this is where I think even most journalists and all sorts of other people who've been really working this story have been very surprised. And again, Elliot, you'll be very familiar with legal documents. They're usually incredibly dry and a very

Tim Stillman6:48Difficult read. This is not dry. And the language in it is is very out of character for what is effectively a kind of I d I don't know if it's a legal document, but a charge document. Using a word Yeah, yeah.

Elliot Smith7:05It's a press release, really. You know.

Tim Stillman7:08But e even if you read I haven't read all of it, there's a 40 page judgment type thing. The language in that is not what you usually read in these things. And even using a word like sham as well, sham, which is a very colloquial kind of word that a fan might use on Twitter. You know, tells you and what they say about witnesses as well, and it's very like d using words like lies, you know, again you will be very familiar. You don't usually read that in these things, and I think that tells you again the gravity, the seriousness, but and I might be being naive here, but I think I've read this reasonably well the whole way through, there just can't be any way that the Premier League will go that strong in their wording. And how lawyered do you think this thing is? Like it's been three years in the making and it's been a few months since they kind of told everyone. Like how many sets of legal eyes do you think have gone over this? And they've presumably and they've all gone, yeah, you can say that. And that that's very, very unusual. And I think that really tells you something.

Elliot Smith8:27Yeah. I wanna emphasize something because we're gonna talk about the city response to this and what's gonna come next in a bit, but this was a multi-year process. It was over forty days of hearings, it was over seven thousand pages of documents, it was dozens of witnesses, it was a panel of three expert reviewers, independent an independent review board. Whatever you read out there by anybody who wants to say, I've seen this and it Pokes holes in the they haven't. They haven't seen as much as this independent commission has seen. They haven't put the time in. They haven't put the expertise in. Not to mention that City spared no expense on their legal representation. If there is a case they could have made to refute these charges, they have made it as forcefully, as thoroughly, and as competently as possible with the expert legal representation that they have at their disposal. The fact that the findings are so concrete, so clear, so thorough, the fact that the Premier League statement is so forceful tells you how clear the case against City was. Because if there were holes in it, do you really believe that over those 43 days and those 7,000 documents and those dozens of witnesses and those

Elliot Smith9:53Millions of pounds of legal fees, they would not have found those defenses and put them forth? Of course they did. So the fact remains there was a thorough independent process. There was an appeal process following that related to certain aspects of this. They have lost all of it. Almost completely. A hundred and fourteen of 115 charges. And so the thing about the statement Tim that really strikes me is two things. One it is so forceful and so damning that it is an open war now between the league and one of its member clubs. Given how forceful they were and what they reported, it suggests to me that they will be seeking extreme punishment. I don't see how you can put a statement out like that and still intend to be in business with Abu Dhabi United Group. I don't see how you can. I mean, realize again, a league is essentially just a joint venture of 20 member clubs who come together to engage in one sporting and commercial enterprise. That's what they do. Tim.

Elliot Smith11:05Based on the forcefulness of this statement, let's talk bigger picture and then we'll get smaller picture. Bigger picture. Do you believe that this points in the direction of the Premier League essentially tipping their hand that they will not do business with Abu Dhabi United group in the future and that that club cannot be owned by that group and continue to participate in this league?

Tim Stillman11:24Yeah, i it does look like that, doesn't it? It's very I don't think the Premier League are in any doubt about who and what they are taking on here and the resources available to them and the reach of this thing. And th this is what I've always said. Like the fact that the Premier League introduced those charges in the first place immediately told you they were serious. Immediately. Thing they've got on their side in terms of evidence and again I think it's worth reiterating this comes off the back of leaked emails that we can all see right so like that that that is kind of CCTV man holding gun you know that's like that that that's very, very strong evidence and I imagine that underpins a lot of their confidence and things like that. And, you know, we're we're beginning to get I was li I was just listening to Philippe O'Claire on the Ars Cast and he was talking really, really well about like you know, like, th so and so might consider legal action and Philippe was saying, you don't report that if you're a serious journalist. That is not news.

Tim Stillman12:45Someone thinking about doing something is not news, right? That's propaganda. That's PR when you when you do that. If they do that, then you report it as news. But X's consider it that's that's that that could be interpreted as bringing pressure to bear.

Elliot Smith13:05It's exactly what it is, yeah.

Tim Stillman13:07Yeah, yeah, and I think it's clear that a lot of people are gonna interpret that we're we're seeing we're or we're set to see quite a lot of that at the moment. But I absolutely do because like I said, from the beginning, the charges incredibly serious, incredibly long investigation, lots of resource and effort, no leaks. That tells you they're serious from the start. And so everything that's happened in the intervening three and a half years and the Premier League that of course they wouldn't been in any doubt from the start about what would come their way in terms of Manchester City fighting this or rather Manchester City's ownership fighting this and I very much doubt that anything that's happened in the last three and a half years has made them think, ooh, they've actually gone quite a bit lighter on this than we thought. They haven't really bothered with this. Like, I'm pretty sure they understand the gravity of kind of Manchester City's rejection and objection to this. And they're still coming out really swinging to the point that, like I say, like people who have been looking at this and working on this a lot have been like, Wow, I d I

Tim Stillman14:19I did not, a lot of people saying, and I mean, for whatever it's worth, I was in this camp, like, didn't expect that many of the charges to stick. Like, certainly did not envisage a world where they, you know, where they were found innocent of every single one of them. But a lot of people surprised at the number of charges that have passed a guilty verdict at this stage, but also to come out swinging like this and in an environment where the report had been you know, David had dropped the report like four days before, and you've seen the discourse and you've seen the briefing and you've seen everything that's gonna happen, like 'cause it was all kind of out there and I think rightly people kind of understand when David Ornstein puts something out, you can kinda take it to the bank and they still went were not perturbed by everything. So it absolutely looks to me like very much like yeah, an act of war, basically. And I don't think I don't think the Premier League will be under any illusions as to as to what's coming their way. And they kind of I can't say they seem fine with it, but they seem prepared for it. So we'll have to see.

Elliot Smith15:41It's not gonna be pleasant and City are gonna do everything in their power, but I think it's important to remember there is a process here that has been respected, and that process is spelled out in the Premier League rule book, and those are the rules that all the member clubs agree to and agree to be bound by. So it's a tri it's a tricky path now for City to go anywhere else. And I mean obviously the influence campaign is something I'll wanna talk about in moment, but can I just ask you for this season, Tim? Moresque is gonna be asked about it constantly, the players are gonna be asked about it constantly, all the managers are gonna be asked about it constantly. It's gonna be the forefront of everything that happens this season. You now have, referees who have to refere referee matches with the cheats. You know, I mean look, we poke fun at referees because we say, they're all from one pub, they all drink at the same pub in Manchester and they're all from the Northwest and you know but that is kind of true. And that truth cuts two ways. And the other way it cuts is they're just guys who love football at some level, grew up loving football, care about their English football, care about the football pyramid and the Premier League. Now they have to objectively adjudicate a sporting competition with these cheats involved in it. This is a really, really hard thing. And

Elliot Smith17:01I just I don't see how this carries forward and not have doesn't have repercussions for this season. So do you want to game out how you think this season might go? Obviously City go to Anfield next and we make fun of the City pool romance. But I do think that Liverpool are one of the teams that really got screwed the most by all this. So how do you see this being dealt with in the in the near term? How how do you even have a season with these guys involved in it?

Tim Stillman17:28Yeah, I think this and that's another part of the statement, right? The Premier League kinda saying, we're moving towards sancti I wouldn't be surprised if they already know what they think those sanctions should be. And they're saying they want it as quickly as possible and that that's quite right, 'cause it's gonna be a big old black mark over this season the longer it goes on. And it's one of those things who knows how much it will die down in the conversation once the international break ends, the Liverpool game happens, other stuff happens, someone gets screwed by VAR, something, the news cycle moves on. It won't totally move on. It the best really that can happen, from a PR sense, th it dies down a little bit, but it won't. And w what we know is everywhere Manchester City play, it will be a talking point because the fans in the stadium will make sure it is a talking point. To varying degrees of kind of vociferousness. But I mean An Anfield, if you were writing the Premier League soap opera, Anfield is where you'd have the A Anfield or Old Trafford is where you'd have them next.

Tim Stillman18:40So that that's gonna kick it right back off in the news cycle again. I think the other thing I deliberate on with the Premier League statement is I'm kind of speculating that I imagine they had this kind of time and date ring fence for a little while. Do you think it's a coincidence that it's in the middle of the international break? Like that keeps it at the top of the news cycle for a couple of weeks because frankly there's nothing else to talk about anyway. So the news cycle doesn't move on. And then there's Anfield, that is going to be the big talking point. I bet the viewing figures for that game, you can probably add another million to them, quite frankly, in the UK, 'cause people are gonna get it get the popcorn out. They don't care about the game. They're going to be like, we want to see what the Liverpool fans are going to be chanting and what they're going to be saying. And that's going to be you know, a big part of the curiosity around Manchester City's fixtures. And to your point, Moresco will be asked about it every week. The Manchester City women manager, Andre Jeglertz, he was asked about it. Because you know, the women are in a busy period fixture wise at the moment. So he was asked about it, even though the women's team aren't directly implicated, because I

Tim Stillman19:58Believe their separate accounts and all of that. Obviously they'll have benefited just from the kind of money the club have made. But it's it's gonna it's gonna be dicey like that. And it seems to me from Manchester City's response that their response is bring it on. We we will drag the we will drag this through the mud as much as we possibly can. And to be honest, they started on that road a long time ago. It's probably difficult for them to come off of it. But we're we're at a stage very quickly and I said this on the last pod about, the UK Prime Minister was until very recently the mayor of Manchester and that that it that that's how high this is all gonna go and indeed has already gone.

Elliot Smith20:45Yeah. Yeah. It just gets really tricky. D does the league want Manchester City to win a title this season? Surely not. Surely not. I'm not trying to be conspiratorial here. I'm just saying like this is where we're at now. And honestly, shame on any of us for not keeping this center stage fully in focus the whole time since this started. We always knew this was a sham, that these revenues were a sham. The revenue went up during COVID. It was always a sham. What's so brazen about it too is how little money they asked for, based on the reporting that's in the findings, how little money they asked for from their sponsors and how much they put in themselves. They probably could have gotten more money from their sponsors. Whatever you think of them, what they took from their sponsors was probably well below market. It just shows they didn't care. They didn't actually care about the money. They just cared about showing the revenue.

Tim Stillman21:38Th I think Jamie Carragher made a good point about this on I think it was stick to football. He was talking about, you know, that the problem for the league with this sort of ownership is they're not trying to make money. Like that that is absolute like at least, you know, listen, I think most billionaires are wise to the fact that you can't make an awful lot of money out of football. You know, I d I think like FSG

Elliot Smith22:04You make it on the asset appreci appreciation, but not on the on the revenues, yeah.

Tim Stillman22:06Yeah, yeah. And and but for them, ki well no, maybe not pocket change, but like what FSG have done, right? They've taken over Liverpool, was a distressed asset at the time because of Hicks and what's his name? J Gillette, that's it. Yeah, because so distressed asset, there's a few things around stadium reconstruction they can probably get over. We can probably add fifteen thousand seats we can probably make them a much better team, maybe deliver some trophies, which happened, and voila. That and look what they're doing now. They're basically selling it, aren't they? Like piece by piece. And they made their money and they're gonna give it to someone else. And but y you have to be really, really good to do that. And you have to kind of buy a big club. But most billionaires they're kind of in this for ego, I guess. And you know, a bit of a bit of a plaything or whatnot. But there is a problem when you've got ownership that lit not like doesn't even consider the idea of making money. They've got all the money in the world. It's not money they're trying to get. Again, most people would speculate, it's soft power that they're trying to get. And yeah, that and that that causes an existential problem for football. And on one hand, I kind of understand why football

Tim Stillman23:32Ball was caught cold by it when Roman Abramovich took over Chelsea because it had never happened before. There was no indication that something like this would happen. It was a little bit out of the blue. But that that door should have been bolted after that and th and this shouldn't have been allowed and what we're seeing and we are going to see all of the well, we've already seen a lot of reasons it shouldn't happen. We're gonna see even more of them, I think, in the coming months.

Elliot Smith24:00Yeah, yeah. I agree with all that. I th I think it is really, really unfortunate when you go back and think about how the football landscape changed and who got hurt by it. And I don't just mean Arsenal football club and Arsenal fans. I mean fans of football in general and the cost of football and the way that was elevated and the way the competition was distorted. And the number of really interesting seasons we could have had in the Premier League and the and the kind of dynamic competition that the Premier League could have been without Manchester City. A lot of people say, without Manchester City, where would be the interest in the Premier League? Sky high. Because real clubs with real fan bases would have been winning things in much more competitive seasons. So yeah, it's it's a real shame. But it does feel to me through the statement and through the findings. That's what the Premier League will seek. And again, the Premier League doesn't get to set the sanctions, they can suggest. But I think it will be extreme. And I have a really hard time after reading that statement, believing that they will allow a club that is owned by Abu Dhabi United Group to participate in their league. Now, the other members have some say in what happens in the league, but they don't have a say in these sanctions. So the sanctions, as I as I understand it, don't have to be ratified by other members of the league.

Elliot Smith25:19So we'll see what happens here. Mm mm.

Tim Stillman25:22Sure on that. I'm literally not sure on I'm not sure if like something like for example expulsion would have to be voted on by the Premier League clubs.

Elliot Smith25:31If the if the if the panel that delivers the sanctions says that the sanctions are that they're kicked out of football, you know, I don't I don't know if that has to be out of. I this is all stuff that we're gonna we're gonna find out along the way. The other thing that I will say quickly before we move into the city side of this is this only extends up to twenty eighteen. I mean, obviously that is a sham as well. They didn't go from Pretending to have 600 million pounds of revenue in 2018 to actually having 610 million pounds of revenue in 2019. That's not how this works, right? They didn't go to Eddie Hat Airways and say, hey, know how you had to pay 16 million for the 85 million sponsorship last year? Well, this year you have to pay all 85 million of it. That's not how this works. Obviously, that's all allegedly. We don't know. But the suggestion that it stopped seems fatuous to me. The idea that all of a sudden they just decided, well, twenty eighteen's when we're gonna start doing right. No, twenty eighteen is when this review the period that's under review for this set of sanctions, but there's a whole period twenty eighteen to present that could be re-reviewed. And there's litigation possibilities from other clubs and potential players, players who didn't get win bonuses, Champions League qualification bonuses, title bonuses, agents. There's litigation from sponsors who may come back and say, you know, we were damaged.

Elliot Smith26:53Reputationally by being associated with this. Cause we were actually one of the real sponsors. We weren't one of the sham sponsors. And by the way, if you go back through some of the sponsorships, it is pretty funny. Companies that have no address, companies that have a president of the company where it's a stock photo. You can literally find the stock photo on pornographic websites. Like I mean, there's there's stuff like that. You can dig into this. It gets it gets to the point of absurdity. There are emails where people are talking about how to do the fraud. Like yeah, it is.

Tim Stillman27:19It's astonishing arrogance in a lot of what's laked. Yeah.

Elliot Smith27:22It just is. And what I love, you know, you're seeing things like, well, actually, no, it's that's not what happened. What happened is the government of the United Arab Emirates paid money into the sponsor and the sponsor paid the money to the club. Look, fraud is always fraudy. There's always lots of layers of the fraud. It's not you don't just do the fraud, you do the fraud in a like creative way. It's still the fraud, especially when your emails say, Let's make sure nobody knows about the fraud we're doing. But we do have to talk about the broader implications of how Manchester City are fighting this. And I want to do that next.

Elliot Smith29:15Tim, one of the th it's funny when you're doing the sports washing, when people are surprised that you did the sports washing. Yeah, they helped revitalize certain areas of Manchester. I think it's important to point out, by the way, from some of the things I'm reading, it's not affordable housing, it's not low income housing that's affordable for people. It's some other issues. It's, it's it's expensive housing and it's gentrification and it's but yes, okay, they had a beautification impact on certain areas of Manchester and they put a lot of money into Manchester. That's all part of it. Because then what happens is you help the mayor of Manchester become the prime minister of the UK. And the prime minister of the UK, who benefited from your investment, all of a sudden, that that chip comes due. And you have to go public. As the Prime Minister of the UK and say, it'd be a shame to lose them as owners. It would. The ones who just got found guilty of a hundred and fourteen of a hundred and fifteen charges of financial improprieties and flouting the laws, it would be a shame to lose them. I wonder why you feel that way. But Tim, this is this is where I want to go. Now they have Eddia Had Airways threatening to sue the league. Of course they're owned by the by the Emirates. They're owned by the United Arab Emirates. The government of the United Arab Emirates or owns

Tim Stillman30:38A c a company not name checked is wondering why they weren't spoken to by the Premier League.

Elliot Smith30:44Yeah, w what are the odds? Point is they are going with the full intimidation campaign plus the Hearts and Minds campaign. Pep had to put out, you I the only thing missing from Pep's statement was a picture of him holding up the newspaper the front page of the newspaper with Day on it. You know, there's obviously players that are circling the wagons. The pre Prime Minister is saying how great they are. Eddie Had Airways is threatening to sue. This is all, in my mind, one big distraction campaign. To try to do two things. One, turn public opinion and two, get the Premier League to relent and just feel like this is gonna be more trouble than it's worth. But maybe I'm being naive. Maybe they really will pull the levers of government to their aid to get the outcome they want. But again, I come back to this point. Even if they go through all of that, I don't see a world where this league that put out this statement wants to be in business with this ownership group. So I don't know how you ever get to a healthy outcome that isn't them getting kicked out. But what do you think of their reaction, their rallying of the troops and maybe you can start with your Prime Minister Wayne and

Tim Stillman31:46Yeah, I mean I can't and won't speculate on the reasons for this, but what's really interesting about I mean Andy Burnham's statement, he said so it could have just been a Freudian slip, he said something like, I can't intervene more and it's like more

Elliot Smith32:02What what have you done already?

Tim Stillman32:04Is that is that yeah, is that like a slip of the tongue? It could be, I guess. But what's for you know, for people who don't know and I s suspect don't know because very understandably they don't care, who are who are not in the UK, like Andy Burnham became Prime Minister relatively recently, and he's kind of it's it's probably too much to say he's in a honeymoon period. However, the previous Prime Minister, rightly or wrongly, became very, very unpopular. He's come in and he's a lot less unpopular, right? It's it's a bit it might be a bit Michael Carrick at Manchester United. Pick your favourite Manchester United legend, who was a decent interim kind of thing. And basically the best that any pr this is probably true in the US as well, certainly true in the UK, that the best that any premier, any prime minister can hope for is that they're basically ignored by the public. Because that means you're not reviled by the public. Nobody is holding like street parties for you as Prime Minister of the UK. You know, so the best you can hope for is that you fly under the radar. And to this point, Andy Burnham has largely done that. Right? He's he's kind of so it I'd be overstating it to say it's a honeymoon period, maybe close to it, but it's like he's done it for a couple of months and everything's nicely quiet and down. He's he's been quite strategic and he's done some like nice quick win stuff, right? Which I think is probably

Tim Stillman33:33A good strategy if you come in as Prime Minister. Dropped bus fares, for example, not very expensive to do. Something I can do in like my first 10 days in charge. Fine, I'm doing that. And what's interesting is this week he's actually starting to take on slightly thornier subjects. So we have something in the UK called the triple lock for pensions, which is very controversial and has created very divisive rhetoric between young and old people in the country which I don't think has been particularly healthy but it's very from an electoral point of view taking that on is is very very difficult because of the ages people tend to vote at he's also started to talk about EU reintegration and the options for that again, which is a very, very unpo is something that previous Prime Ministers have completely stayed away from. We are ten years now since the UK exited the EU trading block, trade agreement, and he's floating

Tim Stillman34:41Maybe partial, maybe full reintegration, which a lot I'm not stating my opinion on this. A lot of people want, but it's again, it's very unpopular because it was there was a referendum ten years ago and the way every other political figure has behaved is and I understand this, I think. It it went to a referendum, it's sacrosanct. But all Yeah.

Elliot Smith35:02Yeah, the people decided, rightly or wrongly, th it was put to the people they decided.

Tim Stillman35:05Yeah, and so it's been the how many however many prime ministers we've had since then. I think the two might be linked, to be honest, that we're going through a lot of prime ministers since then. But you know, most of them, I think understandably politically, have kind of said, Well, it's actually it's my job to execute this. But now we're 10 years out and about 100 prime ministers. Andy Burnham's kind of thinking, actually, we need to review this. So so he's he's he's done some like nice quick win stuff, hasn't really earned too much. Much kind of angst or tirade at the moment, and he's just beginning to do the like, I'm gonna take on the difficult stuff, I'm not like the other guys, I'm gonna be honest about like what our problems are. So it's very interesting politically that he's decided to say something about this, and it is not a popular thing for him to say, and rightly or wrongly, probably wrongly, the

Tim Stillman36:07The vast majority of people are politically apathetic. Most of the UK, to be honest, probably doesn't really care about triple lock pensions, probably doesn't even know I don't even really know what that means. I'm vaguely aware of it. D to be honest, Brexit, most people have a view. But you know, like what it's like. Most people want to get on with their lives and not inter interact with politics. But what a lot of people do interact with in the UK is football, and that is a very tribalish. And that will get people's attention. So a lot of people who do not care or do not understand about triple lock pensions, you know that'll upset some people that it affects there will be young politically engaged people who are like, Yes, we need this to happen, we need more stuff for young people. Most people not really engaged on it, not my problem. What's that about Man City? What are you saying about Man City? I want I want Man City thrown. I am a tribal football fan. I want Man

Tim Stillman37:09City thrown out of the league for whatever reason, either because I'm a huge advocate of financial fairness or because I support Man United and I think it'd be funny. It's like anyone who doesn't support Man City, let's be honest, for whatever reason and for however laudable those reasons are, probably just want Man City thrown out. And a lot of it's just entertainment, isn't it? It's like, ooh. All the team that keeps winning the league might be thrown out. So for the Prime Minister to cast any doubt on that is a very unpopular thing to do at a time when he is reasonably popular and he's also messaging about how he's different from other prime ministers and he will be honest about tackling problems that other people have dodged. So I again I can only speculate. Maybe it's just a bit of a misstep. But it's a I find it difficult to believe that he and his advisers would not be fully aware that that is a very unpopular thing for him to say that has brought him onto the radar of people who probably didn't know what he looked like last week.

Elliot Smith38:18Yeah. It it and I have to say, from a remove, knowing nothing about Andy Burnham, the politician. I raise an eyebrow at the idea that he felt he had to say something nice about them when saying that would be politically unpopular. Well, that's my point. Because if

Tim Stillman38:34Just say nothing.

Elliot Smith38:37Look, the one thing I know about politicians is they're self-serving. That that that's something that I think we can say about politicians. And if they think something's popular, they're likely to say it. If they think something's unpopular, they're likely not to say it. This is almost certainly unpopular, and he said it. And all that says to me, and I know nothing of the details, but it says to me, he felt he had to. And I think there are a lot of people that feel they have to. What I am enjoying is that there are a lot of journalists now who have really found their backbone. Now, I want to be clear, there's some wonderful journalists who have done some wonderful reporting. I think Miguel Delaney, to his credit, has done some. Rui Pinto, who obviously broke these leaks and now is going further and talking about Johnny Infatino, you know, kudos. Sporting intelligence. Why can't I think of his is it Nick Harris? Nick Harris, yep. Obviously great work. Magic hat, our own Magic Hat, in the Arsenal world is has done a lot of research into this and published stuff on social media. There's been a lot of great work, but there's a lot of journalists who now found their spine and are really going in on this. I mean, I would say it like this. This is why you don't want nation states owning sports clubs. This is why this is why sports teams shouldn't be owned by countries, by the governments of countries. Because the

Elliot Smith39:53There's just a misalignment. There's a misalignment of what they want and what they're trying to accomplish and what the ordinary owner of a sports club wants to accomplish. And also the leverage they have and the weapons they have at their disposal to manipulate and bully the organization that they're meant to be a part of. You could say, well, billionaires aren't a billionaire. I get that we do the equivalency thing. I'm gonna tell you something. A billionaire, whether you want to say they shouldn't exist and they're terrible and billionaires are wrong, you're entitled to your opinion on all of that. They're not a state, they're not a government. They don't have the wealth and power and military and negotiating tactics of a government and geopolitical influence of a government, and they have different interests. At a minimum, you'd think that a billionaire has one of two interests profit motive, which if you're going to engage in a commercial enterprise, I'm kind of okay with that. Or vanity. I'm also kind of okay with that, because if what you want to do is win and you're owning a club as a vanity project, like kind of fine with that. What they're not doing is trying to advance the soft power interests of a state. And that creates a misalignment. And again, Please don't do the false equivalency thing. I am not saying that means billionaire's good and state bad. Not my point. I'm saying there are certain things states shouldn't own, and sports clubs are probably one of the big ones. And especially given the importance of sport for the average person, the importance of it as a distraction, what it inevitably does is it brings geopolitics into the crosshairs of sport. And so you wind up in this situation where you have a nation state that owned a club, that defrauded the league, that distorted the competition, that used

Elliot Smith41:20Use the club as a prong in their you know in their in their policy of soft power that they engaged in sportswashing they're now bringing their leverage throughout the UK to bear on this case all the way up to the prime minister. This just should never happen. It should never have to happen in this way, Tim, you know?

Tim Stillman41:40Yeah, absolutely. And and the thing is, I d I don't want to sound like we're evangelizing all the other Premier League owners or anything and this is bad, therefore lots of US billionaires are better. But like for example, one thing again, rightly or wrongly, depending on where you stand, one of the reasons that I guess US ownership I d I d I hesitate to say makes sense in the Premier League is because the Premier League is a collegiate product project, right? It is a democratic twenty clubs, they all vote, they all have like vested interests, they all have shared interest, TV money is shared, stuff like that, they all vote on the rules. And that actually, either by accident or design, fits in with American sports quite well, right? It's like if we if we you know, lots of US billionaires talking to each other about what the Premier League does and doesn't do, that's that's business. That's what happens, right? And whereas, and you can see this in Citi's reaction to this, City's stance is kind of we will, we will

Tim Stillman42:51Slash and burn this product. Like the Premier League. We we will sit here and we will stink the place out. We're fine with that. We're fine with playing all these games, going and winning the Premier League and the moral quandaries that creates, getting booed in every stadium. We don't care. Bring it. Right. Whereas I think you your average billionaire, if that's not an oxymoron, would probably think, I don't want this actually, because A, to your point, either A, I'm here for ego and for my image, and that's not good for my image, or B, I'm here to make money, and to make money I need at least some of the other Premier League clubs to somewhat get along with me. Whereas here we've got you I mean, you described it as a war. That that's kind of what we've got. And Man City again, and they have the right to do this, I guess, but th their kind of response is very much like, Bring it. We will torpedo this season. We will torpedo it all. We will we will sit here and be a bad smell if we have to. And yeah, to your point, that that is not healthy for the competition. And I do wonder if part of the Premier League's strength and conviction in this is because

Tim Stillman44:09Maybe because at least by proxy their thinking is we don't want this kind of ownership anymore. And that there might be some self interest in that as well. They might be thinking, actually, we want more US billionaires 'cause they'll all talk to each other, they'll all get along, you know, and the legal like largely kind of continue as it is. Really there's there's like a sense of cooperation there. These guys know how to make money as well, don't they? So we're okay with that. Whereas th this is like this what we have now is adver something very adversarial. And I do wonder if the Premier League is thinking, even if we can't do this by legislation, we have to send a message that this sort of ownership and this sort of stuff it's it's like a you know, rip off the plaster or, you know, rip off the band-aid for friends on the other side of the pond.

Elliot Smith45:05Yeah, it I do wonder how do you even get an end to this, right? Because they'll appeal, there'll be a sanction, they'll appeal the sanction. The member clubs will sue City for damages, some players will sue City for damages, sponsors will sue the Premier League at the behest of Manchester City's owners, presumably. There there has to be an end to this. And I think cities approach would be look what we can tie you up in forever. Just settle it with us with some kind of outcome we're willing to accept. And I do think maybe, for better or worse, the only way this ends is with everybody who's threatening to sue everyone. Everyone's got their cannons pointed at each other right now. And while the Premier League may have the better case, you could argue that City have the bigger cannons, just in terms of their finances, their geopolitical influence, things like that. So I do think that there is scope for these two to settle on something. But I think the strength of the statement, either, if you want to game this out,

Elliot Smith46:24Was designed to create the starting point way further away from where City wanted to be, so that what the league can fall back to is still a strong punishment. Or it's an indication they've just fucking had enough of being bullied and pushed around and tailed and surveilled and threatened by these people and they're ready to be done with them. It could be the latter. It could be yep. Mm-hmm.

Tim Stillman46:45'Cause I thought that about the initial charges. I thought a hundred and fifteen they must be thinking, if we get fifty of these to stick,

Elliot Smith46:52We'll get twenty.

Tim Stillman46:54We've had a good result. But a hundred and fourteen, that that tells you that they were very well researched. And I do wonder that makes me want all sorts of speculations, like, were there more they left out? Were there other things? Were there thirty or forty others where they were like, We're pretty sure that happened, but maybe we can't properly prove it or whatever, that I'm sure we'll never find out. But that fascinates me as well.

Elliot Smith47:21It's an interesting one because Chelsea probably survived annihilation by Roman being forced to sell. Because if Roman hadn't sold, the things they did would probably have been reviewed and the punishment probably would have been extreme. But he did sell, was forced to. And that probably saved Chelsea, and in the they get a slap on the wrist. You could say that one way out for these owners would be to sell and tell the story that we don't believe we did anything wrong. But the threats to the club are so severe for its existence that we will sell out of a love for Manchester and Manchester City. Because doing that protects this club we love, and they can scurry away and be done. And then City gets not a slap on the wrist, but more of a slap on the wrist than they would have if A Doug stayed. But I don't know. I mean, I if you told me that they go to war over this and both sides, you know, take the nuclear option, then my guess is City lose. I know they have all the influence, but I think this process has been respected. I think it's been thorough, and I think they have a hard path from here back. I also don't think we're years away now. Because when the 115 came out, it always hung over City in a way. And you could say, what was years for that? This is too sharp, too forceful, too pointed. I don't think you can just play the games and have City in your league with this hanging over them.

Elliot Smith48:40For years and years. I don't think they will, I don't think they can. So I think there will be a swifter resolution to this than people expect. What that will be, anyone's guess. But based on how the response has been worded, I don't understand how these organizations would stay in business with each other. And I do think that a sale of the club would give them an out, but I don't know if these owners have any interest in doing that, especially with the resources they put into the local community. They may feel that their project, their sports washing project is far from concluded. I don't know. We'll have to find out. But there's gonna be a lot of lawsuits threatened, a lot of cannons pointed at people, and someone's gonna have to make the first offering to resolve this. I do think the easiest way it gets resolved is they sell. They just sell, and then the clubs agree not to sue City, and the owners and the sponsors agree not to sue the Premier League, and the Premier League agrees to do a weaker penalty than they should have if the owners sell and this is over. It would be unresolved in my mind in some way, but that's what I think's happening. I think we should tie this one up because Ultimately there's gonna be a long way to go and speculation can only take you so far and we wanna be careful about speculating. Obviously, all this is based on reporting. We're gonna talk football next week. So we're gonna talk about the academy players. We're well, I say we're gonna talk about football. Matt's gonna talk about finance and debt and Chelsea, 'cause we love this sort of stuff. We

Elliot Smith49:55Will obviously then start to look forward to the Leeds game and get back into football a bit, but this is this is the story, and we wanna keep it in the spotlight because putting football back in the spotlight actually gives them the cover they want. So we'll keep it in the spotlight as long as we can. Tim, as always, I appreciate you. This is a short one today, but you know what? We're gonna be talking about this for a while.

Tim Stillman50:12Yeah, short but sweet. My pleasure as always.

Elliot Smith50:15Okay. Thanks everybody. Thanks for hanging with us as we try to parse this and make sense of it. We're continuing to do the best we can with the information we have. But it's nice, it's nice to see that this is finally at a place now where it doesn't look like it's going to be pulled back into the shadows. And we need to make sure that doesn't happen. All right. More to come. We love you, and we will talk to you if Arsenal 10 leads now.