EpisodesThe Main PodSeason 2026/27

Arsenal’s Stars Come On To Help Deliver Big Win Over Lille

Episode 1042 · · Elliot with Tim

0:001:37:52

DownloadOr listen in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Pocket Casts, the AVP app or RSS

Show notes

On this edition of the ArsenalVision Podcast, Elliot is joined by Tim to discuss Ken Friar’s passing, the Lille game, the rest of the CL fixtures, a Forest Preview and a bit on redundancies at the club.

Original theme music by Paul Hepker

Chapters

Tap a chapter to play from there.

Watch it

Transcript

It's automatic, so expect the odd misheard word. Ads in the audio can make it run a minute or two later than the times shown.

Read the transcript

Elliot Smith0:27Manchester City found out the hard way that everyone thinks they're a sportswasher until a real sports washer walks into the room. This is the ArsenalVision Podcast. My name's Elliot Smith. You can block me Twitter, Aink Gunner. That's right. They thought they were the Kings, but they met the real king of sportswashing, PSG finding a way to beat Manchester City in what was, I confess, an entertaining game. And I have to say that when you have the wealth of nations at your disposal, you can build teams that are capable of playing some interesting football against one another and ultimately, you know, if you eliminate all the ethics and regulations from football, I think you can see that we'd we'd all wind up with matches like that every day. But I don't think that's what we want. Having said that, it was quite fun to watch City get beat. They made it an interesting watch, but they did not make it a close game. And I think it's a reminder that, you know, with a weakened Arsenal team, Mikel Arteta brought us to the precipice of beating that that PSG team. And, you know, given the fact that their idea is if a player just had three weeks off of international break, they will rest them in the league so that they have rest for the Champions League. That's what we're all up against, trying to win the Champions League, folks. So we'll see. Having said that, not all the Giants had an easy go of it in midweek. We'll talk about that. Of course, we'll talk about Arsenal. We're going to talk momentarily about the passing of Ken Friar and a bit about the redundancies at the club. I do want to let you know that Friday Night Clive is tomorrow. We're going to dissect the attack. How we attack, how we can attack better. If we are attacking better than maybe we think. I don't know where the answer to any of these.

Elliot Smith1:56Things but Clive does and he's going to give us those answers. We would love to have you at Patreon. Champions fifty's the code, a couple quid. You will literally have a podcast every single day about the arsenal stuff you love and sometimes about stuff you don't love. Because, you know, we want to mix it up. There was a one club yesterday. Tim and Clive did that. If you want to hear about what is, well let's put it this way a fertile women's season for discussion. I think we can say that so you can listen to that. But I've been droning on for quite a while and I haven't even introduced the man who will drone on with me and his name is Tim Hellatin.

Tim Stillman2:24Hello there.

Elliot Smith2:25Yep. Thanks for doing the One Club yesterday. I always find those really entertaining. And as someone who doesn't regularly follow the Arsenal women, I actually think the One Club pods are great. They give me an instant ability to digest what's happening with Arsenal women without needing to be in the weeds of it to totally get what you're talking about. So I really appreciate it.

Tim Stillman2:45Yeah, no, it was good episode. Well, it was a good episode, but like, unfortunately, as, is usually the case, as you will know from making content, there is a lot more to say when things are going wrong than when there isn't. And I was at Renée Slegers' press conference today with a list of questions as long as my arm, basically, I could have asked the 10 questions. I had to whittle it down. So that's, that's just life when things aren't going well. It's, it's like you say, it's more fertile ground for discussion, but hopefully Clive and I did it justice in 60 minutes.

Elliot Smith3:18I thought you did a great job. If I do say so myself. Okay. I do want to get into the Leo game and I think it's a really interesting game to discuss, but I want to start with the passing of Ken Friar quickly. And rather than doing any kind of unnecessary introduction with my perspective, I think you're better placed on kind of understanding the context of who Ken Friar was to the club and what we've lost in his passing. So do you wanna just say a few quick words about Ken Friar?

Tim Stillman3:42Yeah, what we had with Ken Friar is kind of unprecedented and I mean like in English football possibly European football like how many people do you think have worked for the same football club for seven decades? Not many. Maybe

Elliot Smith4:00None, no one?

Tim Stillman4:03No like probably at amateur level. You know there's a few people like that kicking around. Club the size of Arsenal I can't I can't imagine there are many at all. And it's unrepeatable, I think, you know, doing it in the kind of era I guess he started in, which is like generations ago, you know, like we're talking just, you know, like, just after the Second World War. And, and actually, kind of interestingly, in terms of a line through Arsenal's history, he took over the club secretary position, I believe, from a guy called Bob Wall. Who worked at the club for over 40 years, I think, and actually had quite a similar career to Ken Friar, came in at a very junior level and worked his way up. He actually wrote a book, Bob Wall, called Arsenal from the. No, sorry, that's the Bernard Joy book. He wrote a book about Arsenal in the 1960s and with a lot of kind of tales from the Chapman days, many of which I think were apocryphal. But, but Ken Friar, yeah.

Tim Stillman5:09The story for those of you who might have heard it Arsenal signed a striker in the 1930s from Bolton called David Jack and there's this story about how Herbert Chapman went to meet the Bolton directors and he went with Bob Wall and he said you know when we order a round of drinks we're gonna order whiskeys like whiskey and coke my drink will have no whiskey in it their drinks will have double whiskies kind of thing which is very unlikely to be true, unfortunately. But anyway,

Elliot Smith5:39I wish I went out with him more often. As long as he's picking up the bell, yeah.

Tim Stillman5:43But I mean, Ken Friar wouldn't write a book about Arsene or anything like that. Was, I think like the word I'm coming up with most is statesman really, you know, in terms of almost like a good kind of politician. And I appreciate that politician's a dirty word, but a good statesman, someone who's got an ear on all sides, but knows how to talk to people, knows how to talk to people within the game, knows how to talk to supporters, knows how to balance all of those things. And I think he was clearly an extraordinary administrator. The work he did around the Emirates in particular and the move to the Emirates, that's his. Massively tangible legacy to the club. And obviously there's the Ken Friar Bridge and we already had the kind of miniature statue which shows him playing football, which is exactly how George Allison saw him. You know, someone who's very, very local grew up right next to Highbury. And, but you know, don't stay at a club like Arsenal for 70 years because it's a nice story and you live around the corner. You do it because you're very, very talented.

Tim Stillman7:04At what you do and to do that from basically being a boy at the club and all of the intel and all of the things that he learnt but his ability to move with the times as well because again it's all very well taking up a position in the football club in the 1950s and 1960s but how does that really relate to doing something like moving to the Emirates? It's another world, it doesn't really but you know overall I think as well just like all of the things we like to think about Arsenal, some of which we'll talk about later that might challenge some of these assertions, but we like to think of Arsenal as a classy club who do things a little bit differently. And I think if you were looking for a human embodiment of that, think Ken Friar is one of the two or three people in Arsenal's history that would go straight to your mind. And there's few better or bigger legacies than that. So a life well lived and someone who I think will be very missed.

Elliot Smith8:03Yeah, yeah, well said. And I like said, don't have a lot to add to it that that would improve on what you've said. So I will just give you Mikel Arteta's comments. He he had quite a lot of comments after the match, before he started his presser about Ken Friar, but it'll simply say, quote, the legacy Ken is going to leave to all of us, to our football club, to everybody that has been close to him is going to be forever. I want to pass on all our love to his relatives, his family, so that they know the way we feel about him cannot be anything but extraordinary. Lovely words from Mikel there, well said and a good place for us to move on.

Tim Stillman8:36I was going to say, Elliot, sorry, just before we move on, there's something that might appeal to you in particular. On the Ken Friar Bridge, people will know as you go over the bridges, there are little posters of former players. And on the Ken Friar Bridge, there are players selected by him, his favorite players from over the years. And again, who's better positioned to do that? When Cesc Fabregas is on that bridge and when he signed for Chelsea, someone tore it down. And he insisted it go back up because he was like, look, he's one of my favorite players and you know, we're a club of class, we're a club that recognizes our history. And he was very much like, no, it's going back up. And he did. Like he had, I know it's a small cosmetic thing, but like the courage of his convictions as well.

Elliot Smith9:22Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, I back him on that one. I know not everybody will, but I you're not gonna get an argument from me. So let's let's talk about the little game first. It was an interesting week of Champions League football. And our next opponents, by the way, Bayern Munich, lost Michael, not only didn't beat Viking, but lost Michael Olise to a red card in that game, which means he will miss their game with us. So just a little bit of a boost there. I did like that when Mikel Arteta was asked about Michael Olise not being available for our game. That his comment was laser focused as you would imagine. He said, I am excited about the beautiful challenge. I hears he says, quote, I think the beautiful challenge will be Nottingham Forest away. So he would not be drawn. And kudos to him because that is going to be a challenge. And we'll talk about that a bit. Tim, any surprises from you with how we lined up against Lil? I would say that it's unfortunate timing for both Zubimendi and Hincapié, who almost certainly would have started this game. I think. My biggest regret, if you wanna then that makes it sound too strong, but a bit of a regret is that Declan Rice had to start and play an important role in this game because I don't think he would have had Zubendi been fit. But otherwise, I think we basically saw the team that I expected and I was really happy to see Urian Timber get a start. So that was that was encouraging as well.

Tim Stillman10:43Yeah, yeah, it's pretty much exactly what I expected as well. I'm with you. Think Zubimendi would have Zubimendi and Hincapié would definitely both have started. I think it's it's really I guess the one part I was looking at was left back because it was like, he going to go to Calafiori or, you know, is is Lewis-Skelly's kind of left back era totally and utterly over? And I'm glad it's not. Actually, not least because I think at his age, just staying involved in the team and getting those minutes is really, really valuable. It just keeps him in touch, particularly because we probably have come to the stage where Bruno is going to take over that role now. And Myles has done an amazing job minimizing the absence of Bruno Guimarães and kept his place for the Leeds game as well. Like what Myles has done there in the first kind of six weeks of the season is really, really great. It probably is at the stage where Bruno is going to take over. Just having that left back role there, it just keeps him there, just keeps him involved. And I really liked that. Was really glad that he did that. And particularly because, know, Calafiori doesn't even come on. And I think we've seen enough evidence, you know, now to that he's a player who needs minutes looking after. So and also I think it helped us contextualize maybe some of the lead selections a bit more where

Tim Stillman12:10Maybe a few of us were like, no Ezzah against Leeds. You know, we, I talked about in the last pod how I wanted to Gyokeres start against Leeds and that didn't happen, but it looks very much like Mikel was looking at this and going, we got Leeds at home. They've been really good for several months. It's going to be really difficult. We got Forest away. We know how difficult that is. Lille's the one where I'm going to bring some of these players in and he's looked at it, I guess, as bit of a block. And I think. Therefore that reduces I think maybe some of the anxiety particularly over Eze and Gyokeres where you go they really feel quite peripheral but now they've started this game kind of think okay there was clearly like a bit of a succession plan there. So no great surprises yeah right back's another one you have your eye on but I'm really hoping that we can just begin to see that nice rotation at right back. As well between Ben White and Uri and Timber, because we've just never had it. They've been like ships in the night and hopefully we'll see the inverse here where hopefully Ben White's fit and will stay fit and that can help us ease Uri and Timber in a bit so he gets half an hour against Leeds, an hour and a bit against Lille, you know, so we can so because we never get that. It's always like one of them's injured and the other one comes in when they're not

Tim Stillman13:34Quite fit like help. Help us to ease Timber in a little bit and really get that rotation like we've seen at left back between Calafiori and Hincapié. I think that's really going to add something to our team, not least because Timber and White are very different as well. They're both very good, but in very different ways. And I think that's that's a really interesting dynamic that we can that we can use. And we saw it in this game as well.

Elliot Smith13:59Yeah. Yeah. This look, can we just be honest for a second? Like these teams in the Champions League are not good enough anymore to live with us. They're just once upon a time, Leal in the Champions League would have been like a credible opponent that we might have struggled with and really needed to go full tilt just to make sure we could get over the line. Maybe at home, not so much, but the golf in quality is extraordinary now. And just to put a bit of a point on this. We had 54 touches in their penalty box. They had three touches in ours and managed four shots in the game. And I, and they were lively in moments, but honestly, the golfing quality is massive. And we do have so much talent that we can rotate and we can still look very, very good. But no matter how good we look, Tim, the focus is understandably going to go to how we attack and how we create chances and how we score goals. And there's always going to be this. Redux, the transfer window redux, right? It's because we didn't get this player, we didn't get that player. I mean, fundamentally, I think we're playing really well. But I do understand the anxiety because once again, it was a dominant performance. It didn't necessarily create the clear chances and the goals that it should have, at least early on. I wonder what you make of that first half in terms of how you evaluate.

Elliot Smith15:26The inability to convert dominance into chances and where you assess that in terms of level of concern you have when you watch this.

Tim Stillman15:35Yeah, a little bit. We haven't scored a first half goal in a while, have we? So, and that's a bit of a trick. We're kind of winning games with our bench at the moment, which is a good thing. Like that's a really kind of positive thing, but at the same time we're having to do that as well. And in some games I think that's. More, I don't know, forgivable is the word, but it's probably more understandable than others. Sunderland away, like I said, Leeds are a good team. I think that's understandable. Whereas in a game like this, you kind of think, should, you know, should, should this have happened a little bit earlier? That said, I guess what slightly allays my concern is this was kind of the B team attack really. Whereas and I appreciate it's difficult because the context is so difficult. Was 65 minutes. We've just gone 1-0 up. But when Saka, Havertz and Odegaard come on, it's like, here, yeah, this is the A-Team now. And this

Tim Stillman16:43Is kind of what it's supposed to look like. Like I say, kind of maybe it's slightly difficult to judge because of the game state and everything else. But yeah, maybe. In the first half, although I think from the beginning, from the very beginning of the second half, I think I was never nervous. Wasn't clock watching at any point in that second half. I do that. I know when I do that, like I was starting to do it against Leeds, maybe because we were one nil down as well. Like you look at the clock and kind of go, God, how long? I didn't do that once. I was like very, very confident the goal was coming. I guess also because I knew that who and what was on the bench. So yeah, I guess it's been a bit of a theme about slightly lacklustre first halves and to be fair that happened with quote-unquote the A-team on Saturday as well so I can't just level that of the individuals that were on the pitch. Yes, I think it's a wrinkle at the same time. I'd be surprised if in two to three weeks this was any sort of discussion let alone

Tim Stillman17:50The whole season. Think it's probably just, it's a bit like the set piece thing, right? Not scoring from set pieces. I kind of think that's probably just a variance thing or just one of those little mini events that happens for a couple of weeks and then it just goes away and everyone forgets about it.

Elliot Smith18:07Yeah. We are creating the moments to score goals. And I think this is where you have to distinguish the challenges we've had in the last few games, whether it's the Brighton game or the Leeds game or this game, from when I thought we weren't playing well last season. When we weren't playing well last season, I thought there were two things that were happening that were a little bit alarming to me. One is I just didn't feel we were able to progress the ball very well to get in hurtful places, to control games with our possession at all. The other thing is that we just weren't creating chances. We did not look threatening. And I do think that this is different. I think the start of this season, we have overwhelmingly dominated games. In most games, I think we've looked like we can press, we can recover the ball in dangerous areas, we can possess the ball in the ways that we want to, and create openings. It's just been a failure of execution. And while I'm not going to hand wave failures of execution in the attack as being unimportant, I tend to think those things. Have a little bit more variance and ebb and flow to them than when your overall play and patterns of play are not working. Right. And so when I see us getting into those kind of dangerous positions, Tim, and creating the kind of moves, I that's at least a big part of the mission accomplished. Obviously, getting the goal is the last and most important part.

Tim Stillman19:28Yeah, totally. Okay, let me put this through a bit more of an individual lens that will probably make people shout at me. A

Elliot Smith19:32Hmm. I love that. As long as it's not me.

Tim Stillman19:37Lot of discussion about Pachai Osaka during this season so far can't connect to it at all because he's shooting at goal loads and the way I see it, if he keeps doing that, what do you think is going to happen?

Elliot Smith19:52Score goals. Yeah.

Tim Stillman19:54Score a lot of goals right so for me it's just like keep doing that the ball will go in you're really good someone like yocarez for example my issues with him what's my issue with him my issue is not so much i don't get wrong i've issues over like his technical presence and stuff like that i could get past all of that if he was having five shots a game i wouldn't care like alexis sanchez did he give the ball away yeah was he frustrating? Yeah. Did I care? No, because he had loads of shots at goal and made loads of key passes. So for me, in terms of attacking, attacking is a game of volume. Like over 90 % of attacks don't turn into goals. So you've got to get your head around the fact that attacking is a game of volume. So most of your attacks are not successful, but if you keep shooting, you keep building up pressure. You keep putting teams under pressure. You keep shooting at their goal. They break and it will go in. The odd day it might not, but generally speaking, it goes in, right? And you win. And you win having missed most of your chances. Again, my favorite stat in the Premier League, big chances missed. Have a look at who tops that every season. They're going to be names you recognize, right? So yeah,

Elliot Smith21:14Holland, Salah, it's always the best players.

Tim Stillman21:18Yeah. So for me, like you, I don't want to hand wave lack of execution because it's an issue and the better players execute better, right? Than the others. But for me, I just don't worry about that as much. Listen, I'd love an attacker who is in that kind of executes more often than not kind of category, definitely. But attacking is pure volume, right? And I wouldn't necessarily hold him up as a smart man. But football wise, Harry Kane's pretty smart and he worked out early in his career. He really ruthlessly boils it down to if I get three shots between the posts in a game, I'm very likely to score at least once. And that's his whole thinking, not his whole thinking, but that's a big part of his thinking. Yeah, I mean, it might be, there's probably, why do you think Cole Palmer's good at penalties, right? Like,

Elliot Smith22:10It might be. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Tim Stillman22:18You know. When there are no thoughts in your head, there's less anxiety,

Elliot Smith22:20Yeah. That and the sound of a nice ocean breeze. Yeah.

Tim Stillman22:25Right? But yeah, Harry Kane, I remember him saying this in an interview, he was just like, I worked out, if I shoot, if I get between the posts, I shoot. If I do that three or four times a game, I'll probably score one. On a good day, I might score two or three. The odd, terrible day, I won't score, but generally, that's the idea, right? And so the more we do that, don't get me wrong again, I think if we got another, if we'd got Vinicius or someone like that, we'd probably do it more often. But that's the bit. And all of the kind of metrics I look at and the eye test about our improvement in open play, I think it's there for all to see. And even in terms of execution, like 20 open play goals, that's a lot. That's, that's, that's really a lot. And we haven't even really got Bruno going that much yet and he's one of those players who really should unlock a lot of that and by the way some of his first time passing in this game, think maybe in the build-up to the second goal where No touch bang. It's going first time you look at him in the build-up to his winner against Leeds He gets fouled and he has the presence of mind to scoop that ball up. You're not standing in front of it. You're not kicking it away

Tim Stillman23:45I've got it and we're starting again. He's just, there's a real economy of touches about him. And I think when we really get him going, it's not perfect. It's not going to be with the players we have. It's only going to get better in the market, I think. But I'm really pleased with a lot of the stuff I'm seeing. And I kind of think and hope there's probably more to come as well.

Elliot Smith24:07Was a colossus in this game. I mean, he had the big chance missed at the near post, which wasn't great. But I mean, even just that position that he's getting into, right? Arriving on the cutback from Timber. It's a beautiful move. He played a sensational pass to Myles, who had the cutback to Eze, where Eze hit it tamely at the keeper. I was really surprised Eze didn't do better there. That's the one place that you really think he's so composed and so effective. But that was a nice move that Bruno created, and he just he did everything. He had a tackle by the touchline in this game where he got up and gave it two fist pumps at the crowd to get everybody G'd up. He plays with that level of intensity, but there's a lot of quality in his game. And when you look at the data behind what he did in this game, you want tackles, he had seven, right? The most by anybody in the game. You want shots, he had five. The the most by anybody in the game. Tied with Eze, actually. You want touches in the opposition box? He had seven. Only Eze had more. And by the way, that's four more than the entire Lille team had in the whole game, right? So you just start to look. You want touches, by the way? Tackles, shots. He had the

Tim Stillman25:12Tackles and shots, we like those. They're very easy for us to see.

Elliot Smith25:16Most touches in the game, 96 touches, by the way, the most of anybody in the game. So like he just did everything. He was in 15 ground duels, won nine of them again, the most ground duels won by anybody in the game. This is what I'm talking about. Like a midfielder who doesn't just want to defend or just want to attack or just want to pass. He wants to just do all of it. If he can score the winner, he wants to do it. If he can tackle someone aggressively and take the ball off them and G up the crowd, he wants to do And he wants to do it at a thousand miles an hour. It's great. I loved it. A midfielder who I also love, it took me a while to warm up to him, but who wasn't good in this game. I think it's fair to say and whose role is so confusing to me because every time he gets near the box he scores a goal and you feel like you have to eat humble pie. And then every time he's not near the box, you say, What is this player? And that's Mikel Merino. And Tim, he hasn't had a lot of minutes this season. When he's played for Spain, he's been basically Lionel Messi. But for Arsenal, it's it's been a bit of a stop start season so far. And I just can't help that when he plays in midfield sometimes I

Elliot Smith26:17Don't know if it totally works for him. He was a little sloppy in this game. He was a little bit out of position at times, and he was so frustrated with himself with one loss of possession that he gave away a really bad challenge. I mean, I'm not gonna say it's a red card. It's definitely a yellow, but he's nowhere near the ball. He knows he's not getting it. He's just taking out some frustration. It was it was an uncharacteristically poor and I thought unsophisticated kind of performance from Mikel Merino. I'm curious how you think about not just his performance, but how we get this player more integrated into what we do, because he seems too talented not to be utilized, but these midfield performances do leave a lot to be desired.

Tim Stillman26:55Yeah, it's a weird one, isn't it? And I think also, especially like playing Odegaard's role, like he's not going to play like that, is he? And that like, no, no.

Elliot Smith27:04No. You wouldn't want him to. I don't I don't want him on the ball that as much. I want him doing things first time between the lines,

Tim Stillman27:12Yeah, I think the thing is with Merino, his best areas are in front of his own penalty area and are kind of like the last 20 yards of the pitch almost, which is quite a weird thing to say about a midfielder. But I think, and I think that's also why he's such a good like closer finisher, whatever you want to call it, because I think he really helps in certain game states. If we're winning, he helps regulate a game, right? He helps win you that foul, gets the ball on the edge of the area, know, sticks his back out. No, I felt a hand down. I go free kick. There's 20 seconds gone. Good at passing the ball when he's, he's good when the game's slow. I think maybe I think that's how I'd, how I'd term it. Which is either when you're winning or in the last kind of 10 to 15 minutes. And obviously in the other box you want him arriving onto things, but the actual middle of the pitch, I'm not sure that's that's really his area. Feel like, you know, near the centre backs and near the centre forward, that's where you really kind of see the best of him, I think, whereas maybe in the centre circle, not so much, which is really kind of weird, because what do you do with that player? Because if you play someone in midfield, the centre circle is where they're going to be quite a lot of the time. And so it's why I, you know, I really like.

Tim Stillman28:37The way we adapted to using him as a striker last season, where I think we saw the season before that just sticking him up front all the time had very varied results. Whereas when he played it last season, it was refined. So he was dropping deep and he was getting like Eze running past him and Trossard running past him and almost playing as more of like a 10 or a false nine. And I think that's a good role for him as well. As well, he's quite good, I think on the ball with his back to goal rather than when things are in front of him. He's good at turning away. He's good at protecting the ball. Whereas if you give him the ball, like again, center circle, you've got some space, everything's in front of you. I don't think that gets the best out of him, you know? So it's, it's, it's a really kind of weird puzzle to put together, but at the same time, I do think there's mitigation here that he hasn't started a game in a long time even at the World Cup he was a super sub for Spain

Tim Stillman29:41And I don't know if you read his player Tribune piece that came out today there's a there's an interview and for those of you don't know players Tribune it's like sometimes I have some issues with it because it's a bit player PR but generally they're like in-depth like long read player interviews and the kind of point of them is usually they're quite revealing or confessional somehow. Sometimes about a player's background or upbringing or whatever. But he talked about coming back last season, he talked about the Palace game and he was saying I was really pushing because I wanted to be involved in the Champions League final. That was always the target in my mind when I was injured. We'd get to the Champions League final, that's the game I want to take part in, that's the game that gets me into the World Cup squad. And he said he was really pushing everyone at Arsenal for that game. And so they gave him half an hour against Palace at Selhurst, which was obviously a testimonial at that point. And he said that he said I had to relearn how to play football. He said like the pace of the ball. He said like, I got dizzy because

Tim Stillman30:51I just forgot about the inter, even a game like that, last game of the season that no one cared about, I spent 35 minutes in the concourse. It was a party and he said that I forgot how fast, it was like how fast the ball travels. And don't get me wrong, he's not quite in that scenario. He has been playing football, but like I say, like when was the last time he started a game? He's been coming on 70 minutes, like all summer, all season. So maybe there's a bit of that baked in, but generally I just think there are areas in which he thrives and areas in which he doesn't. And maybe a 90 minute game in central midfield, he spends a lot of time in areas that he doesn't.

Elliot Smith31:33Yeah. Yeah. It's it's a weird game. I mean, he won two of seven duels. He had no defensive contributions. You know, he just he wasn't doing much one line breaking pass, three passes into the final third. The game kinda passed him by, but here's the irony, and this is what makes him such a weird player. He very easily walks out of that game with two goals. He has a header that he really I expect him to score with that. And and that's a testament to the quality I think he has. And then he has a volley from pretty close range where he just he has he's stretching for it a little bit, so maybe a little unfair, but he's in two positions where the ball falls to him and on another day he has two goals. And it's it's just what makes him such an interesting player, because you look at our striker, and our striker who people will find ways to talk about the contributions he's making, I think to just to, in my opinion, maybe lower the bar a little too much of what achievement is. But he comes away another game with no shots and McCalmorino, for as much as I don't think he did right, he gets himself in two very good goal scoring positions in this game.

Tim Stillman32:33Yeah, yeah. And I guess like, if you have Merino in central midfield and Odegaard's there, like a high touch player is there as well, then you reduce, you know, I guess like Rice, Bruno, Merino, that's probably not quite got that kind of more creative balance. You probably want Merino in there when like Odegaard's there, for example, as a bit more of a kind of a compliment to him. You with the kind of high touches and the creativity and stuff like that. And you take her to guard out and then more of that falls to Merino. But but I think some of the data you quoted there suggests a bit of an off day as well, like two out of seven jewels, whatever else he does or doesn't do. You don't associate that with Merino. You you see seven jewels. If you asked me to guess, I'd say five or six one usually. So that that suggests. Yeah, yeah.

Elliot Smith33:25Yeah. Yeah. And even seven's a low number for him. Yeah. It just wasn't about it. Well, look, I mentioned it. Last season we had this Noni Gyokeres Martinelli front three lineup that I think people got pretty frustrated with and didn't want to see a lot more of it. This season's version, I guess you would say, would be Noni Gyokeres and Eze. And it sounds weird to put Eze in that group, but he probably is the backup to Christos Tzolis, and some might argue the backup to Noni himself, who had a very good game against Leeds playing off the left. This was again one of those situations where I think we had such a clear indication of how important partnerships are and how different qualities intersect with one another. Because when it was Odegaard, when it was Saka, when it was Kai, just the precision with which balls were played in the final third, the timing and accuracy and intelligence of that last ball was very consistent. And not only did it get us goals. That that helped us win the game, it created a lot of great chances. It also made Eze look better because I think Eze had a very poor first half. And in the second half you look up and he finishes with a goal, the most shots in the game, the most dribbles completed, the most touches in the opposition box. And it's almost like when he was playing with the more sort of cultured, sophisticated players, he was able to have more of an impact on the game. And I just I do think that partnerships matter, but I guess we can we could start with the Gyokeres part of this, Tim.

Elliot Smith34:55We Kai Havertz and we have Viktor Gyokeres, and that's our striker pairing. And some people would say Kai Havertz, you know, is is good enough. Some would say he isn't. Gyokeres, same thing. I think overall, as a as a duo of striker options, I would I could probably be convinced that we need to level that up. That there's there's another level up we could go to really be at the absolute top of the game. But when it comes to Viktor Gyokeres, it just feels to me like he gets these opportunities. And this is a big opportunity at home in the Champions League against Leo, to, to take the shirt, to say to the manager, pick me. These are the moments he's going to get to convince Mikel Arteta that he can offer something a little different from Kai Havertz, who obviously hasn't had his best games recently, some would probably say. But it again, it feels like it's passing him by. And I wonder how you think about this, because it feels like we get these players sometimes who However you look at the game, it always feels like the post match conversation starts to circle around them. And everything that needs to be said on both sides of the debate has been said. And it gets hard to add anything new to it. And it can get quite tedious. But to me, the biggest takeaway is these are the games where he should be really trying to raise his hand to the manager and say, Pick me for the forest game. And I don't think you could say that's what happened here.

Tim Stillman36:18No, you talk about there's obviously a lot of conversation around the player. It seems quite divisive, which I'm slightly surprised about actually. I don't think there's much tiptoeing around it. He's not good enough. He's not at the level of Arsenal. And I think everyone knows that really. And it just comes down to, am I willing to say it? Am I willing to concede it?

Elliot Smith36:42But but I'll add one thing to that, Tim. I whether people agree with that or disagree with that, I don't even think he looks like he's at the level he has previously been for Arsenal, if the if you seem yes, yes, that's what I'd say.

Tim Stillman36:51Yeah, he's played better than this. He's definitely played better than this. I'm sure there's some low confidence there. Definitely. I think I absolutely read into the fact that he wasn't used at all in August as a kind of if Alvarez changes his mind, you're going into this deal, son. And I'm sure that that impacts his confidence. Kai Havertz is back. I think there's there's definitely a real hierarchy there. And obviously, look, we know two, I think we know two things. I think we know he's not really at the level, unfortunately. And, but I think we know we need him as well. And that means it does make sense to use him in this game because like you said, he's capable of better than this. I don't honestly think an awful lot better, but better and we need him. So you can't completely cast him to the side. Of what I'd do to his confidence. You can't cast him aside because Kai Havertz, no player is going to be able to play every game this season. Even the goalkeeper might struggle to do that. So we need him. Like we're kind of locked into this, I'd almost call it an arrangement really at the moment where we kind of know he's not good enough, but we kind of know he's got a play. But at the moment his involvement as a starter

Tim Stillman38:19Even as a sub in a lot of these games feels like so we don't have to play Havertz, so we protect Havertz a bit. That's more what it feels like at this moment in time. I guess what I'd say in terms of how do we try and build back from here a little bit, I do think he's a bit of a confidence player. I think we saw last season, he went through a little spell in the winter of not scoring and I think it did weigh on him a bit. And then we played Athleti in the Champions League. One when it literally went in off his ass. And then he scored again a couple of minutes later and he got better from there. So I do think it weighs on him a little bit, which in one respect is possibly not surprising because there's so much conversation, know, idiots on podcasts saying things like he's not good enough, you know. But at the same time, I.

Tim Stillman39:19I'm sure he's not listening to Arsenal podcasts. I'm sure I'm not. Yeah, that's absolutely, that's all fine with

Elliot Smith39:22I sure hope not at the moment. After his nice hat trick he can turn he can turn on all the podcasts or send us a middle f a picture of his middle finger, you know? I'd take that too. Yeah.

Tim Stillman39:32Me. But you kind of, you want your striker to either be as unaffected as possible or some people are motivated. Some people in life are motivated by grievance. And I think in sports, that's fine as well. That kind of f you, I'm going to prove you wrong. I don't see either of those, to be honest. I've seen him go into his shell a little bit, but to be honest, I think that's kind of small beer. And the big kind of bullet point is he's just not quite at the level. And we know that and we're in a kind of waiting for Godot situation here, I think, we're waiting to get something or someone better. I'm pretty certain that if and when that, let's say we get an attacker in January of nearly any stripe, I think he'd be the first one we'd be willing to let go of whether there'd be the interest given his age. I'm not sure, although people are always interested in strikers. They do tend to be slightly easier to sell. So I don't know, but yeah, we're kind of locked in this little dance at the moment.

Tim Stillman40:45I prefer to say it as it is and say how I see it.

Elliot Smith40:48Yeah, and I'll I'll contrast that. So Viktor Gyokeres had one touch in the opposition box and thirteen touches in the game and no chances created and no shots. And it's like I get that there are things he's doing out there that you could say this helped or this did that, but fundamentally you get to a point where it's like th this that just doesn't help you win enough. And I'll contrast that with like Noni Madueke, who I will confess I struggle with Noni Madueke. I don't, his style aesthetically is hard for me because he has really tremendous physical athleticism, but I don't think he's a particularly cultured player, and I don't think he makes always the best execution in the final third. But he's doing things at unsettled defenses that do move them around, that do create danger. I mean, the stat that jumps out to me about Noni Mudweke, and I just think that this is kind of the best way I can sum up the problem I have with him is he attempted 50. 15 crosses. I don't know that we need to be attempting 15 crosses as a team against Lille. We should be playing for better

Elliot Smith41:52Chances. Ebrache Eze on the other side attempted zero crosses. Okay. You can say, well, that's not enough. Noni Madueke had one accurate cross from the 15. That sums up what I'm talking about. And I get that this was a cromulent performance from him in terms of creating some danger and getting into dangerous spots. But I will reiterate: when you cross the ball out for a goal kick. Instead of finding a player who's in a more dangerous position or getting something accurate, you give that team that's under the kosh a moment to breathe and to turn your possession into their possession and flip the pitch and things like that. So but like I said, the reason I'm contrasting it is in Gyokeres, I struggle to see where the impact is coming from. With Noni, I do see the impact. I just think, as you saw when Saka came on, the difference between just a well-picked out, elegant ball to Eze for the goal, that's the difference, right? It's that little bit of composure and what a beautiful. Thing it was to see Saka play the way he did and Odegaard and we'll talk about the subs 'cause they really made a difference. Just quickly before we come on to the subs and the goals and the parts of this game where we really stepped on the gas pedal. You want to just have a word about Timber's goal because it's it's such a beautiful individual moment. And for a player who I think is more celebrated for his defensive quality, the way he takes that you know, drags that ball from his in step back to himself to turn to fire it into the net, it's a really, really elegant move and finish.

Tim Stillman43:11It is and we see that a lot from him in tight spaces. It's difficult to get the ball off of him. He's very good at that shuffle of feet. Like technically, I think a really underrated player. We look at him, I think understandably because he's such a good defender and he's kind of physical and solid and all of that. And he's got a very like stocky, almost like kind of flyweight boxer type build, but there is a lot of elegance in his game. I just think on a personal level, he's clearly, been to something we skip over a lot. He missed the World Cup. Like how old is he? Like 25, 24, 25, maybe 26. In that area. He

Elliot Smith43:50Mm. Yeah, I think that's right. Mm. Twenty twenty five? Is that right? Twenty five. Yeah.

Tim Stillman43:58Missed his prime World Cup in the prime of his career in a title winning season. That's hard. That's really, really difficult to deal with. And I think a lot of it's so like kind of by fur cut now the national game and the club game and a lot of people are, you know, we're becoming more siloed kind of in general and in the way we consume football. So we kind of dismiss the international side, not everyone, but like quite a lot. Like missing the world cup is so, so tough. You know, he just about got the champions league final, but that probably cost him his world cup. That's all psychologically, that's got to be difficult to deal with. And you know I was going to say no player deserves that maybe some players do but not very many like he so it sounds a bit glib but he didn't deserve that you know particularly having missed his whole first season with an ACL like that that that's tough as well so just on a personal level really nice kind of goal for him really well taken

Tim Stillman45:05My mate John, who I sit with, it's funny because we sit in the front row of the upper tier, so we have that almost PlayStation type view of the game. And it can really cause us to just completely reduce what the players are doing because you can see everything and you're just like, why didn't he switch the ball over there? It's like, because over there is 40 yards away and there's about eight players in between. But we both said, as soon as he got the ball, almost PlayStation brain kicked in. It's like, that's exactly what I thought he should have done in terms of, but it's like, it's obviously very, very difficult to actually do, but yeah, like hugely, hugely pleased with him. He picked up a lot of great positions as well in this game. Like he almost kind of did a bit of a Calafiori from the right as well.

Elliot Smith45:50Ca can I say i it's funny you say that. I do find myself sometimes getting frustrated when I look at Arsenal and we've got these talented attackers and they're on the touchline and we've got these fullbacks and defenders and they're in the in the half space and at the top of the box and it sometimes feels like we make this more complicated than it needs to be, but in this case it obviously paid off.

Tim Stillman46:09Yeah, but also I think the thing about that is it's not so much that we're thinking, let's Timber will be better in that position than Saka. The point of it is the disguise. It's the coming from deep. It's the they're not picking those guys up. Yeah.

Elliot Smith46:22Defenders don't know who to step out and cover and Saka's over here, I gotta jump out to him. Oops, I've left the I've left the space where Calfiore or Timbers come into, sure. Yeah.

Tim Stillman46:30And ultimately, listen, I say this as a form of fallback myself, like why did inverting fallbacks come about, like inverting left backs, you know, in the last kind of 10 years or so, it's kind of because it's almost the most dispensable position on the pitch. You know, so one of the reasons I ended up at left back was just because I was, I was usually one of only two players on a team who could kick with my left foot. Usually wasn't as good as the guy they picked to play on the left wing. Like fullback was always like the last position in the playground type thing. And, but like you can, you can risk vacating those areas more than you can risk vacating other areas on the pitch,

Elliot Smith47:16That's fair. Yeah.

Tim Stillman47:17Which is, which is why like we're seeing all this inverting fullbacks and stuff like that. People, and like I said, people don't know where to pick them up and things like that. And you know, the lodge.

Elliot Smith47:26Yeah, look Nuno Mendez and Hakimi wind up. Look at some of the teams now with the best attacks, they're they're fullbacks. Yeah.

Tim Stillman47:32Was getting multiple headers in the six yard box. Know, they're just, harder to track and it's because it's the least risky position to vacate. So that's why we're doing it. And that's why loads of other teams are doing it.

Elliot Smith47:48Yeah, it i it makes it very difficult. They come from a deeper position, they drift into a new position, who follows them, who knows, you know, where they're gonna be, and then if they follow them, do they leave the attacker in a space covered by someone less qualified to cover that player? Right. So yeah, I get it. Look, it worked out in this case. Timber was excellent, it was beautiful goal. I wanna get to the really fun part of this game when Odegaard Kai and Saka came on. I wanna talk a little bit just about the Champions League more broadly. And we still have to get to the forest preview. So there's a lot to do. So let me just say, brands. Yes? Brands. Okay, those were your brands. Tim. So i it's funny Mc Mikel was asked about the triple sub because it's it's the it's another example of us scoring a goal right after he's preparing a triple sub.

Tim Stillman48:41Prepare a triple sub in the fifth minute. And then everyone looks over at the touch line and goes, we better score.

Elliot Smith48:49Yeah, he said, quote, I'm going to do that more now. Preparing a triple sub. But you know, one thing that I do think is being overlooked a little bit, and this goes back to my point that I think we're playing better now than in the period last season when I don't think we were playing well, is that last season when we weren't playing well, we bailed ourselves out with set pieces. And there was this whole thing, well, the set piece, it must not count. But I do kind of get it. I do think that if you score a bunch of set pieces, those goals count and you should get credit for being good at set pieces. But fundamentally the most sustainable way to be good and to score goals is to attack well. And the thing you can say about us this season is our set pieces haven't really gotten going, but we are scoring loads of goals from big passing moves, which is, I think, the stick that was used to beat Mikel Arteta in Arsenal is they don't play good football, they don't know how to score good football goals. Well, we're scoring lots of good football goals right now, and we haven't even really ramped up our set pieces. So that is encouraging. But Bukayo comes on, Odegaard comes on, Kai comes on, and I have to say, like, some of the football we played in that period was breathtaking, was scintillating,

Elliot Smith49:52Was remarkable. And the thing that stood out to me, we'll come onto the sack a piece in a moment. But the Odegaard Bruno Rice midfield, I think has a chance to be absolutely game changing for us. Rice is suddenly starting to look quite rice like. He finished the game against Leeds at the top of his game. When Bruno and Odegaard were on, he was breathtaking. Bruno, as we already covered, can do it all. And this was an Odegaard game where he was just having the time of his life out there. If you give him that kind of space, he will absolutely kill you. And he was killing Leo. But the trio of those players, to me, Tim, was one of the highlights of this game. And I realized Leal are not sensational and you can't really measure how we're gonna do in the Premier League against how we do against opposition like Leo at home. But that was one of the biggest things I underlined after this game was the way that that trio look together in the way I think it could potentially really be transformational for our tax.

Tim Stillman50:51Yeah, absolutely. We talked, didn't we last season about the rice as a guard. Could we see that more often? I was slightly dubious about that, I think. But like Bruno's creative game scans very, very closely to Urda, God, but crucially in terms of involvement as well. So that's kind of your two creative eights with rice behind them. I still think as a bit too peripheral to play a central. I still don't entirely like him as much in that role. Whereas Bruno, there's no problem with his level of involvement. You know, and there's, there's no problem with him smashing into tackles and stuff like that. Obviously it exposes you to more risk. We saw that against Brighton and this is something I said last season. Don't get me wrong. Felt Arsenal should take more risks on occasion, but this thing we do mentally when we want a team to do more of something, we completely discount the downsides of that. And I think maybe we saw some of those downsides against Brighton and risk looks great until it loses, until you roll snake

Tim Stillman52:06Eyes. But in a game like this in particular, where particularly home games where you just know you're going to be on top of the opposition. And all of that, it's, I think there's a hell of a lot of potential in it. And the fact that we just haven't really seen it that much yet, ironically, other than Brighton, which was a game where perhaps it didn't work as well as it could have. But I think Arteta was very forthright about particularly about Bruno off the back of that game. And I think something we could probably say this quite early stage about Bruno's character. I think he's unlikely to let that happen again, and I think Arteta being quite forthright and outspoken about it. Think Bruno's,

Elliot Smith52:52It was so interesting, yeah.

Tim Stillman52:53I think Bruno's going to take that message on board very, very quickly and kind of go, yeah. All right. Fair enough. And actually like Arteta is, it's interesting as well in terms of his, you know, communication and all of that. Like he's always been very like no excuse culture, no molly coddling, but it just feels like he's in such a position of power and authority with the new contract with the Premier League title where he doesn't have to handle those things with key clubs and especially Bruno's nearly 29, so it's not a kid he bought. It's a bit like I bought you to be great straight away. So be great straight away. And I think Bruno will accept that message quite quickly. So I'm really excited about these three. Did when I did the column last week. I did, three things I'm looking for in this block. And one of them was the Bruno Rice in particular kind of partnership. But I think that is going to try like that. That feels quite firm. Bruno Rice, Odegaard, even though we haven't seen a load of it from the start of games yet, it just feels like no one's taking Rice's position while Odegaard's playing like this. No one's taking his position.

Tim Stillman54:10So and Bruno's already showing really, really encouraging signs and we know the player, we know who we bought. We paid a lot of money for a guy who's 28, 29. We didn't bring him in to be a maybe a bit of a rotation player. Can add some value. Like a bit like that. That's kind of what we bought in Mikel Merino, right? I think when we bought Mikel Merino, I don't think the idea was this guy's going to be starting every single game, central midfield playing every minute of every game. I think the idea was this is a really smart senior squad piece who can come into the team, come out the team, be on the bench, be good around the training ground. Bruno's clearly assigning where it's like this guy's going to be in the team. That's what we want from him. And so the Rice Urde Guard Bruno thing, I think it's clear that that was the thinking from the very start of this season. And one of the exciting things in terms of our progression is we haven't really seen it get going yet. But we got a little taste of it in this game and it was very nice to watch indeed.

Elliot Smith55:15I loved it. Yeah, I absolutely loved it. And I just I think like you know, Bruno is at the heart of so many things. I mean, for the for the Saka goal, it's it's a beautiful moment of we win that ball, hey up the pitch, Odegaard gives it to Bruno. Bruno plays a beautiful ball into Saka. Pardon me, this for the Eze goal, and then Saka cuts back. He he was he was involved, Odegaard was involved. There were there were some beautiful flowing moments, but it also I think gave Rice such an exciting platform because he Rice has this thing where he never looks like he's fast without the ball, but he covers so much ground. I can't explain it.

Tim Stillman55:56Acceleration is mad. When you kind of see it in front of you, yeah, he gallops.

Elliot Smith55:58W yeah, when he really stretches his legs, he just carries away from people. He gallops. It's cr it's crazy. He recovers the ball. He does this thing where he'll be running at someone and you think, uh-oh, there's gonna be a big collision. He has the ability for a very big physical player who is running at full tilt to actually in a very kind of technical way take the ball off the opponent. You know, when he when he gets a ball recovery, he doesn't go through them two footed, stomp on their ankle, barge them over. It's just he's such an impressive player. I think this was a really exciting thing. And I would expect that those three will start at Forest. So Saka gets his goal. Mikel Artenna had an absolutely hilarious comment about Saka. On his conversations with Saka about his mindset, Mikel said, Quote, after the press conference, I went and he was on the massage table and I Bukayo, I just killed you in the press conference. Good luck tomorrow. Was laughing. He knows me. He knows we have these kinds of things and he takes it because he wants to be the best version of himself. In order to do that, you have to set big objectives and challenges and try to raise them by working, being consistent, and he has the ability to do it. Tim, Clive and I on the Monday pod had a conversation about Saka, and we were critical of his performance against Leeds, but I think in a more circumspect way, and talked about he's getting into positions, he's

Elliot Smith57:17He's in the right areas, he has the right involvement, he's not executing at the level we expect. And I think people felt that we were too easy on him, and some people articulated that in the forceful manner of internet communication that you'd expect. But this is exactly what we're driving at, which is Bukayo Saka having an off season by his standards, but he is getting into really good positions and he is influencing play in the right areas and just not getting the final bit right. And I really believe to your point earlier about him, if he does continue to do that, it will bear fruit. He wind with a goal and an assist in this game. He looked absolutely fantastic. And I think for a player like Packayo, this is exactly what the doctor ordered. Because you could say, well, Leo's not the toughest opponent. I don't think the level of the opposition's been the problem. I just think Backayo's been the problem. He just hasn't been kicking the ball right. You know, the shot, was it the Leeds game where he shoots over and you expect him to do better? Like I just think having a couple moments like this where he gets it exactly right might just help him sort of settle into the groove a bit. But he looked great. And I think the underlyings are there for Bukayo to really have a big season,

Tim Stillman58:21Yeah, hugely. I think also I've been thinking about this as well, because it's so clear, like things have changed, the positions, the number of shots, it is so clear that they've kind of come to, think, a very logical conclusion, which is we couldn't really improve the attack like we wanted in the transfer market. We need to score goals, more goals. How are we going to do it? Well, let's try and get our most talented attacker into those areas. Like I think it's a pretty simple equation. But then I've been thinking, okay, why has he still scoring goal? The way people talk about him, you think he hasn't scored this season. It's like he has scored goals and I've been looking, closely at like the shots. It's like, what kind of shots are there? And I did an article on it a few weeks ago and there's lots of running off the back of the full back. It's lots of getting into central positions, lots of attacking the back post when the ball's on the other side. And I think probably what he has to finesse is the type of finish that we're kind of asking for him is almost that Trossard finish that arriving onto the ball first time again, like Robert Pires, the absolute master at it, arriving onto the ball, body round it, bang, it's gone

Elliot Smith59:36Yeah. Curl it. Mm-hmm.

Tim Stillman59:39In first time type thing. And a lot of that and Trossard great at that as well. And a lot of that. How you arrive onto the ball, how quickly you shift your position. You know, can you do it with very little back lift? Again, think of Trossard's most famous Arsenal goal against West Ham. When that ball gets cut back to him, is he taking a touch? Is he making sure it's the porridge is just right? No, he's like, he sees the pass coming and he sets himself so that once it's touched back, he's already. It's like the bow and arrow kind of thing. It's poised to let go.

Elliot Smith1:00:18Yeah. Just let it go. Yep.

Tim Stillman1:00:20And I think that's probably the area that Sacka's working out at the moment. Because that's a slightly different thing where he's been doing more kind of cutting in from the right, shift and shoot, almost that iron robin type thing. Whereas this is a different type of finish. We're asking from him to arrive onto it, kind of sweep it in. And he does that in this game, albeit it's quite close range this time. He should score that, but I think that's where it's been that kind of stepping onto the ball, arriving on it, you know, almost setting yourself before the ball arrives so that when it does, you're, in that kind of flow. Think maybe it's slightly staccato in terms of like, the ball's arrived now. I've got to shift my feet. You know, I think it's like, it's probably just a really small technical thing and Arsenal probably have like, three or four coaches who are employed to do just that, you know, somewhere who, yeah. And so I can, I can see that sorting itself out in no time.

Elliot Smith1:01:26I look, I realize that there's anxiety about this because Bukayo Saka is now on our record wage. He's our star attacker. We don't have the talent in the attack, in my view, that a club of our stature and our ambition probably wants to and expects to have. And so a lot of the pressure falls on Bukayo Saka to be the player of that caliber. I just think he still is. And I think again, you know, I remember having these conversations about Obamiyang. When Obama Yang was getting seven touches in the box and four shots, I was never complaining. Obama Yang would miss big chances. That was just who he was. He would miss chances that would frustrate you. He also won two golden boots at Arsenal. So I think of Bukayo Saka is getting the ball in the right positions, making passes in the right areas, taking shots from the right areas, that fundamentally I'm still gonna feel pretty relaxed about it. If Bukayo Saka starts averaging one and a half shots per ninety and two touches in the opposition box and, you know, no no chances created, that then yeah, we're we're gonna have a very different conversation, but that's not the situation right now. So last c couple quick points here, Max Dowman got on. I don't think it was a particular eye catching moment from him, but we should just keep remembering that the process when you're sixteen years old is just play some football at the top level. Any minutes he gets at the top level is good for him right now. I do worry about Max in one respect. He's close enough to the first team.

Elliot Smith1:02:53That he's making first team squads every game. But he's not so good yet that he's getting the amount of minutes you'd like to see him play. And I do worry, would it be better, Tim, if Max Dowman was playing regularly for the U 21s versus making every match day squad for Arsenal, but playing either zero or 10 minutes? Again, I'm not concerned about the talent level. I have no doubt about it. I just think at 16 years old, what you need more than anything is football. You don't want to stop playing competitive football. And I realize he's training with Arsenal, which is probably a higher level than most U21 games are anyway. But would you prefer to see Max playing more regularly at youth level? Or is that just beyond him at this point? And the just getting into the flow of being in match day squads on a match day and learning how to be a professional is more valuable for someone of that caliber.

Tim Stillman1:03:44I suspect it probably is. Yeah. And obviously you've got to balance the risk between stagnating potentially by not playing enough, but you know, overloading, on a player of that age. Cause it kind of happened to Wilshere. Wilshere kind of arrived at like 16, but then, you know, to your point, wasn't really playing in the under 21s anymore. He was too good for that, but he wasn't getting a lot of minutes. And when he was, I think when he was 18, he went on loan to Bolton and the first couple of weeks he was horrible there. But once he got into the flow, he really finished the season very, very strongly with them. Think Max is, I think Max is literally too young to go out on loan. I don't think you're allowed to loan 16 year olds, even if, even if kind of you think it's a good idea, maybe I'm wrong about that, but. I found something really interesting that Arteta said before this game about him potentially playing on the left and Tap the Mug wrote about this today, like that left wing spot, that's the lowest barrier to entry in this Arsenal team at the moment, right? And there's potentially three players who could kind of launch their Arsenal careers if they could nail that. Eze, one, Madueke, another, and Max Dowman.

Tim Stillman1:05:05And, but what was interesting when he came on, he went to the right and Sack went to the left. So even after saying that, Arteta kind of wasn't prepared to do it on this occasion, but he said something like, it's easier for him to play there. On the left, that is. And I very much took that to mean it's easier to get into the team there, as opposed to it's easier for him because that's his best position. I just think that would be a really interesting development, even if it's not where he's going to end up long term. Because like I said earlier about Myles, just playing left back in this game keeps him in the game, keeps him getting minutes, keeps him an important player. If Max could take some minutes on the left, I think that would like really. And again, it might not suit him at all. You can't just do it because it's convenient, even if it would be convenient. But even if he could take 15, 20 minutes on the light, that's where I think there are some minutes basically, potentially.

Elliot Smith1:06:10This is where I think we can learn from Arson Wanger. There were a lot of young players, Tim, who came through for Arson at the position that was available. Aaron Ramsey played on the wing, Nick Bentner played on the wing, and I know Arson talked a lot about liking to play players on the wing because they could see the game from there, they could learn it from there, you know, it was a good way to kind of learn their way into the team. But Kyosaka was the left wing back because that's where the minutes were available, right? So I actually think as a young player, rather than Hardly ever playing, and when you do, you're backing up a position that's well stocked and you have no chance to break into, play in a position where there's some minutes available. Because Myles Lewis-Skelly showed, you what can happen? You could accidentally what's the meme? Screwed up and accidentally became important at work. Myles Lewis-Skelly accidentally became

Tim Stillman1:06:53It just keeps you involved.

Elliot Smith1:06:56It be but he accidentally became important at fullback and became our best fullback for a little period of time there, and it really helped us. And what if Max plays off the left, does okay and actually becomes important as a left-sided attacker for us in an area where we have need. So I think that's absolutely right. Look, we don't need to go much further on this. I'll ask you briefly just about the Champions League more broadly. Bayern Munich failed to win. Real Madrid came back to beat Rome in a crazy game 4-3, but they looked poor and then they turned it on a bit. City obviously lost heavily to PSG, but in a really fun back and forth game. You have a take on the landscape of the Champions League as it is right now? I think we know the goal is to peak in April or May, but we also saw last season that finishing top of the league table phase has big, big impact on your ability to get to the Champions League final. And we now have won 14 consecutive games in the Champions League group phase, which is pretty impressive in my mind. So what are your what are your thoughts about this competition overall and what you saw in it this week?

Tim Stillman1:07:56Yeah, I feel like this is quite a circular discussion that we have every year where the group phase kicks off and we go all the Premier League teams are just so much stronger than everyone else. But then there's almost like it's almost like starting on the outside lane, and then it gets to the knockouts and all the Premier League teams are absolutely knackered because they're playing grueling games every week and PSG emerge from hibernation. Know, and real Madrid and Barca can do that to an extent as well. They're in close races often with each other, but that's not necessarily translated into all the fixtures they're playing. So, you know, Barca, Real Madrid, Bayern, they can rest players in March and April and it's harder for the Premier League teams to do that. So I think it's a manifestation of that again, you know, the power of the Premier League, particularly against like Villa 160, did they or? 6-1? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Elliot Smith1:08:53Six nil. Six nil. Yeah.

Tim Stillman1:08:56And look, this is kind of what the league phase is. It's kind of inconsequential as well, to be honest. Like a lot of tickets on Tuesday night ended up on the exchange. Although most of them seem to be snapped up, which is good and a sign of the system

Elliot Smith1:09:15Mm. That's good. Yep.

Tim Stillman1:09:16Working, but a lot of people kind of don't bother with these games because they're like category B. So it's like 60 quid and up and a lot of people are like, even if we lose, it probably doesn't mean very much. And that's just what the competition is. In the league phase, it's a revenue generation exercise and the kind of the real stuff as it were. I guess it's a bit like international tournaments, albeit there's a novelty to those because they don't happen as often where the group phase of a World Cup and a knockout phase of a World Cup are very, very different. It's just the group phase of a World Cup is like quite fun and colourful when you get like new teams and new players and new stories. And then you kind of go, that was really nice. Pack all that away in the loft. Now it's like France v Germany or something. The Champions League, guess, because of the annual part of it and because obviously revenue counts so much.

Tim Stillman1:10:22Is a bit less. It's almost like something you just have to sit through and get through, to be honest. Yeah, but the very firm pattern seems to be that Premier League teams are too strong for everyone until they get tired in the spring and that kind of evens things out a bit. And then those teams who have massive, massive financial advantages in their own leagues, that's when they start to really profit at this time of year. To be fair, Byan drew with Augsburg, I think, at the weekend, but they know they can afford to, probably.

Elliot Smith1:10:59Their bogey team in the Bundesliga. So Yeah.

Tim Stillman1:11:03PSG I think are fifth or something, but again, I'd be surprised if they're not top on 1st of November,

Elliot Smith1:11:09It's like when you play against your small child and you let them score on you once or twice the bit you know, y I when I was growing up I had a I had a friend who was much bigger, taller, stronger and better at basketball than me. Which honestly that probably explain yeah, well I was gonna I was gonna say it's probably dif

Tim Stillman1:11:24Just one friend.

Elliot Smith1:11:26A very big group, but we would play one on one basketball all the time. And like I'd get out to a five or six nothing lead because I was too stupid to realize he just wanted to make it somewhat competitive for himself. Yeah.

Tim Stillman1:11:38It's like an arm wrestle where you just.

Elliot Smith1:11:39That it's like yeah, yeah. It's like PSG versus la Lee Gun or Bayern in the Bundesliga. By the way, the last thing I should say, Tim, I like it when people pay homage to our podcast. And if you aren't a patron, and we would love for you to be, we do the stocks rising and stocks falling in every instant reaction. And I wanna say thanks to Lisandro Martinez for paying homage to our stocks falling section by giving his director of football is stock falling, following their lost athletic. If you have not seen this, find the quotes. It's easy to blame the coach, it's easy to blame the players, but what about other areas? I have to control myself a lot, but sometimes it is the reflection, the mirror for our club at the moment. I expect more from everyone, more investment. Yes, 100%. I expect more from our technical director. I have to be honest. For me, we don't have the best squad at the moment compared to other teams. I couldn't agree more. Well said. Do love the stock falling for the technical director. You don't you don't see the technical director getting his head called for at the end of Champions League games much, but that's in fact what Lisando Martinez did and he's walked it back since then. And it's also quite funny. Last couple points here, Tim. It's Forest at the weekend. Forest away.

Elliot Smith1:12:50Not a great fixture for us. And yeah, I mean, I have to say you would expect that we'd be fine, but I've expected we'd be fine before. I think I wanna say I think this was one of my lower moments. Last season. Am I right? Was this the January fixture where things started to go a little bit sideways?

Tim Stillman1:13:06Yeah, well we could have gone 10 points clear by winning.

Elliot Smith1:13:10Yeah. So I one thing I'll say that Mikel's been great at in his tenure, I think, is writing wrongs, getting the team fired up to write some wrongs. So maybe this is a wrong that we can write. But what do you make of Forest and what you'd expect from us against them on Sunday? And it is Sunday that we play, despite the fact that we then go to Germany in midweek.

Tim Stillman1:13:28Yeah, so I think a lot of the same the last two games there have been nil-nil. What's interesting is Forest have won one of their last 14 home games in the Premier League. They haven't scored at home this season. So they lost to Leeds, they lost to Coventry and they drew nil-nil with Spurs and they went out of the League Cup at home to Leeds losing 2-0. So the City ground hasn't been nice to them. Unfortunately, I don't think we're going to see the benefit of that because I think personally, I think that's more to do with the opponents than the venue. Albeit, interestingly, Glasner had that issue at Palace. Palace had a very poor home record under him. And my thinking around that is that Glasner teams are better set up as counter-attacking teams. So they lose at home to Coventry. They lose at home to Leeds. They draw with Tottenham like this is all relegation fodder all round really. But I think against a team like us, where the impetus is not on them necessarily to take the game to teams, I think they're more comfortable like that. They won at Villa Park. That's their only win this season, I think.

Elliot Smith1:14:39Out Anfield in a game where they outplayed Liverpool.

Tim Stillman1:14:42Yeah, yeah, exactly. They drew two to Anfield. I just think those games suit them quite a lot more. And, you know, in terms of this potentially being another nil-nil, statistically the two best defences in the league. So our XG against is just under five and I think theirs is seven. It's the second best in the league. They play three centre backs, obviously under Oliver Glasner. So it's going to be maybe similar to Leeds in that respect. So even though they've had issues with conversion, they've got issues at home, I don't think those are going to count for a great deal. And interestingly, their next three home games are us, Man City and Chelsea. I bet they pick up a few points there. Hopefully not against us, though. It's, you know, listen, a first half goal for us would be very, very nice, wouldn't it? Basically, but I think this is going to be, it's going to be tough. It's going to be attritional. They're going to, they're going to sit back and look to hit us on the break. In Morgan Gibbs White, they have one of the best players outside the quote unquote big six, I think. So I just expecting another really difficult game.

Elliot Smith1:15:59Yeah, look, they have ten f five goals scored on ten point six expected goals. Like the yeah, you hope that doesn't bounce back in this game. 'cause it does feel like teams have been finding the net from places you wouldn't expect them to lately against us. But Morgan Gibbs White's a very good player. That's certainly a player that, you know, I think can and almost did play well, I was gonna say a big club, another club, let's put it that way. It's you it's a Sunday game before we go to the Allianz. You hope that our eye will be on the game at the Forest Ground. The City Ground, I should say. City Ground? Is that right? Yeah. Okay, got that. But I don't know. I mean, I do think, Tim, that these are the games where the big clubs tend to struggle. And you know, look at Manchester City and what are the odds? They have Ipswitch in their game following PSG. You know, wedge between Lille and Bayern, we have Forest away. It's it's a tricky fixture. I mean do you think Mikel will just go to whatever he regards as the strongest eleven we have? Will he have an eye on the Allianz? I think he will be fully, fully focused on this game.

Tim Stillman1:17:07Yeah, I think so. And I think the six Champions League points allows him to do that

Elliot Smith1:17:12Yeah, fair enough.

Tim Stillman1:17:13As well. Maybe if we dropped points in against Napoli or Lille, I suspect, and I suspect that's what a lot of the rotation against Lille was about as well. It's like, Nottingham Forest, then Bayern. You know, we've got Liverpool, Anfield not too far away as well. So I'm sure they look at all of this as a bit of a block. And again, I'm sure he'd. Love to have had Declan Rice's feet up on Tuesday night, albeit Declan Rice did have the whole international break off, but no, I'm not expecting, I'm expecting like the team as it were, as we know it at the moment.

Elliot Smith1:17:51Is the team Myles in midfield or is it now Bruno you think? Is this where he rolls out Bruno at a garden race?

Tim Stillman1:17:57I think this is where he rolls out Bruno Odegaard and Rice. Yeah. I think I'd bet a lot of money on Havertz up front, obviously Sacka on the right. But again, the position that's quote unquote up for grabs, the one that my eye will go to when the lineup drops is the left wing. Is it going to be Eze or is it going to be Noni? And

Elliot Smith1:18:13Yeah. What do you think?

Tim Stillman1:18:16That's such an interesting question as well. I know we didn't really talk about Eze and his performance in this game. It's like, again, included this in the article today. It'd be wonderful to smush Noni and Eze together and get a

Elliot Smith1:18:31Well a Noni with as a technical level is yeah it's a superstar, you know. Yeah. Yeah.

Tim Stillman1:18:34Well, Noni with Ezz's end product. Ezz is a low touch player who has good end product and Noni is like the opposite. And if we could just like splice those together and then take the version that isn't involved and has no end product and like sell them to Spurs or Chelsea or something, that would be a great outcome. But what we do on the left wing over the next few weeks, I think that's going to be really interesting because honestly, the problem is we just don't have the ideal player there. So I'm really interested to see how that changes from game to game.

Elliot Smith1:19:09Yeah, Mikel had a really interesting and maybe slightly inscrutable comment to your point about Noni with Ez's end product. On and on Noni's end product, he said, quote, I said when you talk about players being clinical, sometimes that means scoring five in every hundred. It's about generating volume, more actions, and getting him into the good positions because he will decide matches. He had a really big contribution a few days ago. Today he had a contribution in the last final pass as well. I mean, that was for the timber goal. That's a bit generous. We need to get players to that level to be decisive in every game if possible. And the way he's talking about him, I think he will go back to him off the left. I think he likes the energy that he brings and he did like his performance against Leeds. And he can bring Eze on if he wants to. Those are really the only choices though, I think.

Tim Stillman1:19:58Yeah. And well, it's another back three back five, which is what we had against leads and he picked Noni there. And so I'd be interested. I think there are a things about the Noni selection. He hadn't gone away with England. He'd trained, you know, Mikel said he trained well, you know, he was better than all the training cones and all of that. Sorry. I'm being. Yeah, exactly. He was the best guy in training.

Elliot Smith1:20:16Yeah, 'cause nobody else was out training, they were all the way with their country. Yeah.

Tim Stillman1:20:22Yeah, him, the cones and those like dummies they use as a wall to take free kicks over. No, that's that's being ungenerous. I'm sure he was very good in training. But I wonder if there was something in it being like a back five against Leeds. But then like maybe the way James Justin got some space to score a goal. Forest's right wing back is Munoz, a very dangerous player. So, yeah.

Elliot Smith1:20:46Yeah. Well, I think you've hit on something there, T Tim, which is simply Eberja Eze let a man steal in behind him to score a goal once, and it was a little while that we didn't see him get the opportunity to play off the left again. Like, you know, Noni was a little bit culpable and if I could be critical of Noni for a second, my issue with him against Leeds, he was quite dangerous. It was sort of a Noni performance from an end product standpoint, but he was dangerous and he deserves credit for that. I still think he is out of position too often. And if you watch Declan Rice, if you watch Kai Havertz, if you watch his teammates, there's a lot of pointing and talking to Noni and guiding him through where he needs to be and pointing him back into position. And I know that's such a huge thing for Mikel, but you know, to be fair, maybe he feels as a has that same issue too. So we'll have to see. I think we've got enough for Forest, obviously, but you know, these are two teams that have not been clinical. We're underperforming XG, they're massively underperforming XG. Something's gotta give here. I don't expect it to be a game of huge box action. Someone's gotta be clinical. And I my money is on Bikayo Saka to have a big game, to really have a big game, to build on what he's done, to benefit from that Odegaard, Bruno, and Rice midfield being a little more direct, getting him the ball on time in the space. Look, we have to start getting players the ball on time in the space. Pass appreciation in the first half against Liel was poor.

Elliot Smith1:22:09And pass appreciation, the second half was better and look at what it yielded. So that is I think that midfield is going to help Saka get the ball when he needs to, when he can attack his fullback, when he can attack space. I think Saka's gonna have a big game in this one. I really do, and I think he winds up deciding it. Final point. It was announced that Arsenal are going to make 60 positions redundant at the club. And I want to be careful because I've had this explained to and I want to make sure I'm getting it right. I don't think anyone has lost their job yet. I think the way this works is you announce that you plan for these redundancies and that the roles are at risk. You then go through an evaluation period that's required and you then let people go. Some people may get reassigned to other new positions that have been created. Some people will lose their job, and their job will not be replaced. So none of that has happened yet, which means we don't exactly know. I want to be careful and I want to make this point as clearly as I can. Whatever your perspective on redundancies, human beings need jobs to live. And whether you think you're good at your job or bad at your job, losing your job is not something you plan for and not something that is easy to live through. And so certainly my heart goes out to anybody who's affected by this, these wonderful people who help make our club what it is. And again, whatever your opinion of their position and its need to exist, these are human beings who will be potentially, if it happens, losing their job. So I just want to send

Elliot Smith1:23:34Our thoughts of support and care and concern for them in the hope that they will find a soft landing should they need one. But having said that, let's at least analyze what we think of this. Tim, Arsenal hired Boston Consulting Group to do an analysis and consultants do what they do. They get paid big money to save little money. That seems to be the consulting grift. But do you have any strong opinions or thoughts on the club deciding to do this at this point?

Tim Stillman1:24:02Yeah, so, mean, because obviously I don't know, the ins and outs of it. And that's that's often not an ideal position to kind of be opining from. However, to your point, like, you know, a consultancy kind of firm coming in, like, you know, you pay them two million to save you three million like kind of thing. And it does feel particularly brutal and cutthroat just after Arsenal won the league. They got the highest revenues and all of that. Like I don't know exactly where the job losses are. Maybe like retail kind of thing. I don't know. It sounds like, you know, nothing on the kind of performance side. But then those are the job that, you know, those are like those the kind of money we're talking there will be around average. Probably wage for the UK and for London and that's really, really difficult to deal with. It just feels a time when Arsenal's revenues have never been higher. Listen, the timing around like someone like Ken Friar passing in the same week, you know, it's kind of unfortunate, but at the same

Elliot Smith1:25:27Yeah. Well, and Mc Mikel's bumper contract being announced and people are naturally gonna point to that. It it's unrelated. I think it's silly to analogize it too, but all those things happening in the same time window is not ideal.

Tim Stillman1:25:39And look, ultimately as well, I know there'll be a lot of this is business, this is what businesses do. But then it comes down to do you think a football club is more than a business? You know, and actually football clubs are, they're very good at picking and choosing when they do the big like, we're one big family kind of thing. You know, I'll look at the next Adidas drop. I bet there'll be loads of that. I bet there'll be loads of with a classy club of culture and all of that and tied into the community and those things I do think have truth in them. But then like it does feel grimy, doesn't it? It does feel like very, very kind of cutthroat, we can probably say of like what's a bit of a pittance for Arsenal and in the meantime, people and in a job market as well that is not good. At the moment, there are lots and lots of people who are searching for jobs and not able to find them. It is not a good, I want to say era, not even

Tim Stillman1:26:46Time. It is not a good era to be looking for work. And I'm sure lots of our listeners that will resonate because it's really, really tough out there. So like it's, it there's never been a good time or a good era or a good period to be made redundant, but this is an especially bad one. It's an especially difficult one. And I just, doesn't, it just doesn't feel that necessary to me for, you know, for like a football club that's supposed to stand for something bigger and is happy to say it stands for something bigger when it's trying to stuff in particular. So, yeah, it feels a bit, it feels very cold, doesn't it? And just to echo your sentiments, like, you know, there's, there's a real human story. To that that really should be at the forefront of everyone's minds.

Elliot Smith1:27:41I think there's I think that's all well said, Tim, firstly. I think there's three dimensions that I want to talk about this on, and I'll try to do them all quickly, but I don't think you can cover this effectively without touching on all three dimensions. One I've already done, the human dimension. This is people losing their jobs. Whether you think someone should lose their job or not, it is bad, it is painful, it is hard for them, and it will it will cause disruption for their family and for their life. So the on the human dimension it is hard, and you just feel bad for people. You should always be able to feel bad for someone who's going through hardship, someone in the Arsenal family going through hardship, whether or not you can justify the decision. So the human element is one dimension. Second dimension is the optics. I know that's kind of a grimy way to think about it, but let's be honest. Arsenal don't make widgets where the goal is to sell the widget for more than the widget costs and make a profit. That's not the goal. The goal is to get people to care about and root for Arsenal Football Club, and that ultimately generates revenues for the club. And so you can do that by being good on the pitch. You can do that by making cooler shirts, signing the best talent. You can also do that by engendering goodwill. Football

Elliot Smith1:28:51Clubs are in the engendering goodwill business. You can damage that goodwill. And this optically does that. So the optics are bad. At a time when commercial revenues are at an all time high, sporting success is good, the club is moving in the right direction from a financial prosperity standpoint. It's just bad optics.

Tim Stillman1:29:08And we're competing with a team who have the worst optics at the moment. Yeah.

Elliot Smith1:29:12The worst optics. Yeah. Let them kick the keep kicking the ball in their net. Don't kick the ball in your own net. You don't need to do that. So what I would say is hiring for multiple millions of dollars, one of the biggest global consulting groups, to save some millions of dollars at a time of all-time high commercial revenues when you are in the optics and PR business is just bad optics. Okay, so the first dimension is the human dimension, the second dimension is the optics dimension. Now I'm going to give the dimension that I think people will maybe not want to hear about, but I think it's only fair to have a balanced conversation, which is the business dimension. There's a few parts here. One, anyone who's engaged with Arsenal Football Club, I think, would agree that there is always scope, and certainly with this club, for reviewing the way the club operates and enhancing and improving its operations. Anyone who tried to watch the preseason streams knows that didn't go very well. The app launch hasn't been a huge success. The box office.

Tim Stillman1:30:00Anyone who's been dealing with the box office this season, there have been issues. I sincerely hope that's an area that needs more support and resource at the moment. Yeah.

Elliot Smith1:30:10Well, I'm c yep, I'm coming to that, right? So the box office, the streaming, the app, the Wi-Fi at the ground, whatever you want to say, there's there's areas where the club can improve its operations. You know, events. I'm not picking on anyone. I just think that's true. And to the extent that headcount should be devoted to areas where the club can improve its performance, I would support that. You know, if you wound up telling me that forty five of the sixty redundancies were the horse and buggy drivers. I would say, well, actually, okay, that makes sense. What are you gonna put them into? We're gonna put them in the box office and digital and technology. I would go, yeah, you know what? You've made the right call, guys. We don't need the horse and buggy drivers. And I'm not trying to make light of anyone losing their job. I hope I've made that clear. What I'm saying is it is perfectly reasonable for an organization not to take the opinion that every job should exist forever, but to review where headcount exists and make sure that headcount exists in the places that makes the organization better. Because I'll tell you something. If the company, if Arsenal Football Club performs better, what I'd like to see is that it employs more people. And if it is performing worse, it will likely employ fewer people. So I again, I'm not justifying doing this. I do think it is the typical marketing management consultant playbook. It does feel like a nakedly cost-cutting move, but we should at least be open to the potential that as they review these redundancies, what they are going to try to do is shift.

Elliot Smith1:31:33Cost and headcount into areas where the club needs to improve and potentially maybe move out of some positions that weren't delivering value to people who support Arsenal, value to the club, value to the organization so that it can thrive. And you need good people at an organization to thrive, but you need people doing the jobs that need to be done, right? And my hope is that some of these people who are made redundant actually get their jobs repurposed to other jobs. And I, from what I understand, that is a possibility. Maybe I'm being hopelessly naive. So again, human level, horrible, hate it. The optics, I just think the optics is saving a few million pounds at this time with where this club is, with what's going on in football, after hiring that consulting firm, the optics are not good. From a business standpoint, there is still a possibility that the way the club is handling this is for the long-term benefit of the club overall and will allow people to have more jobs that are good jobs inside of Arsenal. I would hope that's the case. And for people saying, Elliot, you're being naive or that that's a perspective that maybe doesn't need to be highlighted. I think it allows us to balance the possibility that there is a defensible business purpose for this. But I wanna be clear that the optics to me and the human element to me are this is a strange time to be emphasizing cost cutting for this club and this not just job environment but commercial environment for the club overall. So, you know, I it's tough, Tim. I love Arsenal Football Club. We're all fans of Arsenal Football Club and we want to defend the shield, but I think it is only right to

Elliot Smith1:33:03Point out when the club is doing something that makes us not as not as thrilled and it's certainly hor you know hard to see people lose their jobs in this way.

Tim Stillman1:33:11And listen, insofar as we have any agency at all, we have a responsibility, I mean as fans, I'm not talking about us personally, although maybe we do,

Elliot Smith1:33:23Well, we fall into that camp. Yep.

Tim Stillman1:33:25Of like making this uncomfortable from a PR perspective,

Elliot Smith1:33:29It's a fair point, mm.

Tim Stillman1:33:30Know? That is the power we wield. As fans, that's the power we potentially, well, probably wield as. Content creators, podcasters, however you want to call it, making it uncomfortable and making it bad PR to do this and making that a consideration as much as possible because even something like the Super League, unfortunately, I don't think it was only because people got out on the streets and protested it. I think there were more logistical, probably cynical reasons.

Elliot Smith1:34:04I think it helped. I think it helped.

Tim Stillman1:34:06But it helped. It absolutely helped. Yeah, absolutely. I look at some of the protests Liverpool fans have done. One they did just under 10 years ago, they were going to be £77 tickets introduced and they all walked out the stadium on 77 minutes. You know what happened the next day? No more £77 tickets. Like there is a value in making this uncomfortable and making it poor PR exercise and as you say, it didn't sound like anyone's lost their job yet. So bringing some of that pressure to bear and

Elliot Smith1:34:38Yeah. Yeah, may change that.

Tim Stillman1:34:41Saying, yeah, saying the optics around this are bad. Think about this guy. Like you're not gonna slip this one under the radar basically and hope that that has some impact.

Elliot Smith1:34:54That's all well said. And and like I said, there are multiple dimensions you can analyze these things from. The human dimension, I think, is the one that that should always be centered because we're too quick to not think about the individuals whose lives get impacted. I think the optics side of it matters when you are in the business as a football club of creating community and creating support, right? That's what you're in the business of. Your entire business is essentially goodwill. So when you damage your goodwill, you're damaging your business. And then there is the final piece, which is simply what would be lovely? It'd be lovely six months from now if a report comes out and says Arsenal now employ fifteen percent more people than it did six months ago. And those people are in really good jobs that were really needed by the organization as they realigned where headcount was. Am I so naive as to think that's where this is headed? No, I'm not. You know, is it nakedly cost cutting? That is certainly the reporting. My hope is that that that does not wind up being where it is, or that the club rethinks how they want to do that. And we want to see the club thrive and we want to see the people at the club thrive and those things are all connected. So it is easy, Tim, to moralize about stuff like this. I think

Elliot Smith1:36:01Finding the right balance between discussing it in an ethically appropriate way and acknowledging the business realities of it i in a way that that is intellectually honest is also important. So hopefully that makes a lot of sense. And and, you know, I think your point is very, very good one, which is if no one ever makes this uncomfortable for companies when they take these kinds of actions, then the need for them to consider whether these actions need to be taken goes away. So play a role there. Yeah. All right. That's a long, long podcast. We got a Friday night Clive tomorrow to break down the attack, which hopefully will not break down on Sunday. And then an instant reaction on Sunday after the forest game, and then we carry on as is it gets to be a really hectic period. So there's going to be a lot of fun podcasting to do and a lot of fun to spend together. So I hope we can all stay together through this period 'cause it's gonna be a big one for Arsenal. So Tim, great job by you as always. I know we kept you up late tonight. We had a later recording start than normal. But it's a Champions League week. It's about staying up late at night. So you're ready for this.

Tim Stillman1:36:59Indeed, yeah, and Nottingham to come on Sunday in Munich next week. Yeah, it all keeps rolling.

Elliot Smith1:37:04Yeah, that's right. We it is kind of crazy. We have what's a 430 kickoff on Sunday, and then we have to go to Champions League midweek. Thanks for that one, Sky Sports. All right. But we can whine about them another time. Hang in there, everybody, and don't forget to you know keep the city story in the headlines too. Let's not let that s slide off the headlines. Hopefully they'll get their booze this weekend. We love you. And we'll talk to you after Arsenal 10. Lead Snell. No, no, no. Arsenal 10! Forest Nell